This is a local favorite! It's reputation of amazing pizza goes back over 40 years. They have a daily buffet in addition to menu items. We LOVE Paglia's and look forward to every visit. It's always a treat!
1 - 10 of 51 reviews
The place was busy. The pizza was not great, but I've had worse. The salad bar was mediocre. They had a very bizarre pizza: crushed oreo? Not for me...... I'd say.... you get what you pay for. $12 buffet. There ya have it.
Pagliai's has been in business since the late '60's & keeps going strong. Thinner crust pizza made right before your eyes as you enter the door. I hear the owner is fantastic to work for & the "townies" and college students flock there, especially on...More
I have been dining here since college (almost 20 years ago), and it is delicious each and every time we visit. The buffet is always stocked, and the pizza is unique, unlike a lot of chain pizza bistros; however, I really come here for the...More
Pagliai's Pizza is a well-known and beloved Maryville restaurant that has been around for more than 30 years. It is a great place to stop for lunch or dinner. My family and I especially enjoy going there for the lunch buffet. There is a large...More