We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Here at McGarry’s, we serve up some of the finest pub fare you’ll ever try, featuring some Irish classics, American comfort food, and some inventive new dishes prepared by our amazing culinary staff. Then wash it all down with a pint from the best beer selection in the area.
We needed to find a place close to Baker Park Reserve and "risked" going here. It was fabulous! Such a nice surprise. Wonderfully spiced (and generous) meatloaf, a Cottage Pie and a quinoa salad with garbanzo beads and grilled chicken and a few other delights....More
We go here for lunch once in awhile for work and you never feel welcome. The food is always acceptable, but the employees seem stoic and kind of grumpy. Today our party of three waited an hour for two lunch cheeseburger baskets and a brisket...More
We used to eat at McGarry's often. The summer menu was light, fresh and delicious! They change the menu w/ seasons but still have the Irish fare all year. The fish & chips are a good "back up" if you aren't certain what to order....More
we went on a Saturday night and did not need reservations. good selection of beers and cocktails. menu has a number of unusual things. we had the turkey wild rice pot pie. loaded with meet and very flavorful. the leech potatoes soup was excellent. other...More
This is a local place, American with sort of an Irish theme. It is clean, the food is good. The service is okay. While they go through the motions, they don't make you feel welcome like they do at the River Inn in Hanover or...More
A little gem with great pub grub. Shepherd‘s pie is excellent and the corned beef is great. Loads of inventively prepared comfort foods available on menu, haven’t had a dish there yet that was not highly satisfying. Gets quite busy so get there early or...More
I was with a group of 12 people just before noon on a recent Friday. I ordered the Blarney Stones (Scott Eggs) and shared those with whomever wished to try them. We agreed they were very good, if not typical Scotch eggs. They were presented...More
Date of visit: February 2018
Thank Donald W
Bill M, Owner at McGarry's Pub, responded to this reviewResponded 10 February 2018
We are so very sorry that we did not live up to your or our expectations. We hope you give us an opportunity to delight you some time in the near future.