Updating Map... 1 - 10 of 74 reviews
I came to the Vineyard for the first time with family who have eaten at Jimmy Seas many times. It was the night of my birthday and as my group of 4 approached the entrance a middle aged woman who turned out to be the...More
Hello, I'm not sure when you came in, we close on Columbus Day and I left the island the end of August, so honestly, I'm not sure if you have the right restaurant. Unless there is a new owner that I am unaware of. Lisa
My group of 7 had many bad experiences at Jimmy Seas last night- miscalculated wait time (15 minutes turned into 45 minutes); they didn't tell us that our table was ready, but told us that they gave it away when we inquired about our seating...More
I have spoken with the staff regarding this. This was the version they provided. Your group came in late, they lock the restroom at 9:30 pm because it is outside and accessible to anyone on the street. No one was "escorted" to the rest room,...More
We were a party of 8 (6 adults with 2 kids). Having ordered apps and salad for the table we decided not to order entries for the kids; plate portions are large and figured we had enough food, planned to share everything family style. We...More
Thank you for your version. I will now provide mine. You came to me at the hostess stand outside, demanding in a loud and hostile tone I speak with my server immediately, stating you were a regular customer who comes every year. 99% of our...More
drink prices were expensive , seating was sparse ... portions were huge and food was bland ..... you could get more flavor out of a jar of Ragu at the grocery store ... sharing prices were high ..... was my first and last time as...More
I'm surprised anyone would give this a poor review. This converted house made a great impression on me and my mother - we split a meal and a bottle of wine; the bartender was very sweet and service was great. A local recommended this for...More
We got to the restaurant 5 mins after it opened and we were met by the hostess that seemed inconvenienced that I asked for a table for 6 plus a high chair. When we were seated the waiter preceded to tell us that approximately 6...More
If you like pasta this is a must while on Martha's Vineyard! Delicious pasta dishes served to you in a skillet with salad & bread. Very unique! Portions are huge! Good to share, although they charge you $12 additional to split- that gives you extra...More
Didn't see this restaurant highly ranked so we didn't have great expectations but boy, were we pleasantly surprised. The bread was warm, and both salads were very good and flavorful! The spicy seafood soup was very tasty and had a nice kick to it but...More
This was once a fantastic restaurant and now it's just marginal fast food Italian. Watch out for the drink prices as that's where they really get you. Prior owner was always there working the crowd and making sure you were enjoying your meal. The place...More
Dishes are very large and (in my opinion) could be split with 3 people. I wish they would do 1/2 orders. Everything was good. My bartender did not know what their heaviest red wine by the glass was. That's ok. He was honest and I'd...More
