We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Amici's Downtown Italian - CLOSED

601 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN 46202-3706
+1 317-634-0440
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
  • Excellent7%
  • Very good18%
  • Average23%
  • Poor29%
  • Terrible23%
30 Mar 2014
“Hidden Little Jewel”
1 Feb 2014
“Good service, terrible food quality”
Restaurant Hours Closed
€€ - €€€
601 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN 46202-3706
All Details
Reviews (38)
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year

1 - 10 of 38 reviews

Reviewed 30 March 2014

This small restaurant is a hidden little jewel in Indianapolis. It is on New Your Avenue about five minutes south of Downtown, Great foods and super friendly folks. prices are very moderate for the quality, and size of the entrees. Don't miss this little jewel.

Thank indytomBallwinMo
Reviewed 1 February 2014

Had 4 different entrees on a recent trip with the family. Every one was horrible - not poor in taste, but horrible. Got some bruschetta - it looked like tomato paste was just put on bread with some mozarella on top. Bland, boring, no taste!...More

Thank Shir101
Reviewed 18 October 2013

Comfortable, raffish and consistently good taverna food in one of the few distinctive neighborhoods (Lockerbie) bordering Indianapolis downtown. You can usually get seated in this creaky old building, which has leaned 5 degrees off the vertical for probably lots longer than the 19 years we've...More

Thank James S
Reviewed 9 July 2013

We were very disappointed with our experience at this restaurant. It is located in an older building in downtown Indianapolis which could have been a neat atmosphere, but tables and chairs were not clean and our waitress had an attitude with no personality. It seemed...More

Thank busy2bme
Reviewed 29 June 2013

Arrived on a Saturday around 5, no one around. Waited several minutes to be seated. Chairs uncomfortable. Table sticky. Server was overly friendly with my husband (he was disgusted by her, she was filthy). She never glanced at me but continually made flirtatious to him....More

Thank kcoston101
Reviewed 14 June 2013

this place used to be well above average as a unique Italian restaurant in Indianapolis. it is still housed in a quaint, cozy, albeit slightly rundown house near the downtown area, but the menu offerings have not remained up to par. the marinara sauce on...More

1  Thank Boilermaker_Indy
Reviewed 15 February 2013

We have been going here for almost 30 years. This is the one Italian restaurant in Indy that is not "trendy" and as an Italian-American, I can get some of real food (that I don't cook at home). The atmosphere is qauint and pleasant and...More

Thank Benjamin D
Reviewed 2 December 2012

I was hesitant after reading some of the reviews. I am so glad I gave it a shot! Dinner was fabulous! The prices were a little higher than others but not outrageous. I had the chicken Botticelli. I would highly recommend it! My husband had...More

Thank Nevesmommy
Reviewed 13 October 2012

I have reviewed Amicis before, and I won't repeat myself. However, we have eaten there several times since my last review, and I continue to be amazed by those who claim that 1. the building is run down or dirty; 2. the service is terrible...More

Thank NanjingBob
Reviewed 12 October 2012

We had been to Amici's several years ago and decided since it was a Groupon we would give it another shot. Big mistake. The place is extremely dirty. I understand what ambiance is, but this is pure neglect. Our food was not good. There were...More

Thank Kellie1633
Nearby HotelsSee all 187 hotels in Indianapolis
La Quinta Inn & Suites Indianapolis Downtown
470 reviews
.58 km away
Home2 Suites Indianapolis Downtown
375 reviews
.75 km away
Ramada Limited Indianapolis
1 review
.85 km away
Hilton Garden Inn Indianapolis Downtown
1,144 reviews
.85 km away
Nearby Restaurants
122 reviews
.01 km away
Bru Burger Bar
791 reviews
.49 km away
The Rathskeller
509 reviews
.40 km away
St. Joseph Brewery & Public House
123 reviews
.45 km away
Nearby Attractions
Sun King Brewing Company
75 reviews
.30 km away
Medal of Honor Memorial
70 reviews
.45 km away
Easley Winery
63 reviews
.21 km away
James Whitcomb Riley Museum Home
33 reviews
.14 km away
Improve this listing

Restaurant Details

Average prices
Good for
Groups, Child-friendly
Open Hours
16:30 - 21:30
16:30 - 21:30
16:30 - 21:30
16:30 - 21:30
16:30 - 21:30
16:30 - 21:30
Location and Contact Information
  • Address: 601 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN 46202-3706
  • Location: United States  >  Indiana (IN)  >  Indianapolis
  • Phone Number: +1 317-634-0440
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing