While I’m a new town for a visit I usually check Trip Advisor to see where’s the best places to eat and what’s the best thing to eat. TA has Nickel Plate as the best in town and reviewers suggested the tenderloin. Boy were they...More
1 - 10 of 202 reviews
We, ten ladies, went to this restaurant to celebrate a friend's 50th birthday. Meal prices were very reasonable. Very cozy place. The waitress was very nice and patient with us.
We hadn't eaten here for a few years and decided it was time to give it another try. Sadly, once again, we weren't impressed. Basically it boiled down to a lot of money dropped for a very greasy, non-spectacular meal. We'd rather spend that money...More
We had to move our drinks and appetizers from the bar to another room because the couple we were meeting brought their young son along. Pam, our server, was terrific about it and gave us terrific service at our new table. Our hat's off to...More
Right on the tracks in the midst of the exploding downtown growth that is Fishers, this restaurant takes its name for the old railroad line that runs alongside. Comfortable seating both inside, and on the patio, that has garage doors to accommodate the changing weather...More
While visiting family in Indianapolis, we learned that the Nickel Plate hosts a group of Steeler fans on Sunday's during the NFL season. We went there to see, and were pleasantly surprised to see and meet so many Steeler fans in Colts territory. The beer...More
My husband and I eat here several times each year. I always get the Hobo Stew and he gets the Tenderloin. We go home full and satisfied. This restaurant has been a staple in Fishers for many years, and I hope it doesn't leave!