We always enjoy the food and service at McCarthys. It's a great go to restaurant for us. Their wine list is good also.
1 - 10 of 216 reviews
We have been here a few times and it never fails to impress. (except one time with a bad waitress but she is now gone). A nice variety of food offerings. Fish is well done as are the steaks and they even have a very...More
Last night we went out to dinner for my mom's birthday. It was our first experience going out to a restaurant since My son has started the ketogenic diet for epilepsy so I was a little apprehensive at first. I called before hand, explained our...More
My name is Libracia Jackson and I want everyone to know about this place right here in the heart of busty old Elkhart. McCarthys on the Riverwalk blew my mind and blew my soul. The service was remarkable and the food had me in a...More
We have been to McCarthy's on several occasions and I've had mixed reviews. The food has been OK at times and good on others. We won't give up and we will try again
I'm happy to hear that you are going to try again. Please let me know what items you have not been satisfied with so that we can work to make improvements on them. Thank you!
i was there on st. patricks day and the food was excellent the serves was outstanding, very polite , the music was good as well , i really enjoyed the place
Maybe it was just the night I went on but my husband took me there for the first time on my birthday and they were out of everything steak wise and the credit card system was down but they did not say that until we...More
Stephanie, I apologize for our credit system being down, we had a week where it would be up one minute and down the next, thankfully we finally got that fixed. I'm sorry we were out of steaks, I don't recall this, but it does sometimes...More
We went for a Thursday night dinner with friends. The service was great and the food was good. Plenty of it. The young man that was our server was outstanding!
That's wonderful to hear! Hope to see you again soon!
Went there with another couple for Valentines Dinner. Food was marginal at best. I had a pasta dish that I could have cooked at home better than they did as a restaurant. Wife had fish that was just OK. Service was subpar, dessert came and...More
I'm sorry that you were unhappy with both your food and service, that is not what we strive for at all. I am sending you a message and hope to hear back from you so that we can address these problems further.