The food was awful, the service was terrible and they added $20 to my bill after we left. It is located on the main road with little parking. The inside is rustic with old stuff everywhere. The only thing I liked was the fireplace.
1 - 10 of 150 reviews
My family has been coming to McCall for a few years and this visit we decided to try this place and it was not good, at all. The wait staff was nice and helpful, but the food was extremely subpar, especially when you consider the...More
Steak ordered Medium came well done. Sent back. Came back rare. Sent again. Still not right but ate the the tough filet anyways. Halibut flavorless and grilled to almost jerky. Sent back. Still over cooked but ate it. Service slow and neglectful. We had to...More
This was not the evening we had planned. We called earlier in the week to make sure the piano player would be in, one of the things on our weekend list, and were assured he would be. I should have checked when I called back...More
I agree with all these reviews about the prices, over and beyond what it is worth. I work here and feel that they are way overrated! Believe me when I say if it were my place the prices would be drastically dropped. Those prices belong...More
We had gone up to McCall for our daughters 24 birthday and the eclipse. We had eaten at Ruperts, My Father's Burgers and Growlers Pizza, so we decided to try the Mill for her birthday. We got there and nobody was in the place, that...More
We started with cocktails. Great mojito, margarita and martini. Then salad and local trout. Very good and plenty to eat. Lovely ambience with tables scattered throughout so seems very private.
Old establised restaurant, good selection, and known for it's prime rib. Good wine selection,good service. the place to see the best antique collection in town. Check out Beside the Mill next door.
We ordered medium steaks they came raw, not even warm. We sent them back, came back the same way. Had a baked potato that had black mold spots inside. Very poor quality food. The water was very good.