Milton took another restaurant down. This town is cursed. This place was amazing and we will miss it.
1 - 10 of 33 reviews
My wife (very picky) said her seafood was great, BUT, don't order the steak like I did, it was a tough as the bottom of an old shoe; it did however taste great. You NEVER order steak at a seafood place, I should have known...More
We come into this place. The décor is ok. The service is above and beyond and the food is out of this world delicious. My mother and I ordered the Captain's Platter with Fried Catfish, Fried Mullet, Fried Oysters, Fried Shrimp, Hushpuppies, Cheese Grits, and...More
Don't know anything about oysters, I happen to hate them. However my dad LOVES them. He says these are the best he's had. We've made it a routine to go here when he visits. And if you're like me and won't eat an oyster to...More
I came in for lunch on Wednesday. The blacktip shark was interesting, and available on a po'boy as well as the plate. I ordered the po'boy. The onions, tomato and lettuce were all fresh, as was the hoagie. The shark had a pleasant flavor, but...More
This is a new establishment. The inside is very casual but we have been very satisfied the two times we've been there. The staff is very friendly. They offer a good variety of seafood for lunch and dinner. The fried shrimp is excellent. Very lightly...More
We stopped on a mid afternoon on a Saturday and had the captains platter for two. The gumbo was very good, the fried oysters were great, the flounder was fresh and tasty and the fries were hot & crispy. I also had a dozen oysters...More
Fresh food!! Had the fish of the day wahoo and it was the best I've had! Not to mention the oysters and the service! Family run and it shows! Not greasy like some places. Every time I visit I love coming here!!! Thanks
I must have ate at a different Captain Pete''s. I was concerned when we walked in and the restaurant smelled of fish - But we stayed to see if the smell was our over worked minds. Two bites latter we left. The smell was an...More
Very convenient right off I 10 in Milton. Very polite staff ζω the food took awhile to come but so worth the wait The freshest catfish shrimp crab and delicious oysters on the captains plate I would absolutely go there again!