My husband and I visited Key West for the day and had agreed we had to test a real Key Lime pie while we were there! We came across Key West Key Lime Pie Co which is just off one of the main streets in...More
1 - 10 of 844 reviews
I'm really not sure why people rave about this pie. I was looking forward to it and very disappointed. Did I get a slice of a pie from a batch made wrong? I didn't taste any lime, just sugar. My husband agreed.
We visited this little shop as part of the Key Lime Bike Tour. Absolutely awesome pie - we savored every bite! There is an extensive selection of candies as well. Very much worth the stop - and take home a whole pie if you can!
We've been enjoying this shop for 4 years now. 2 years ago it changed ownership. They've kept the same recipes. This year we really noticed a downhill in the customer service. The girl running the register said she was new and didn't know answers to...More
Taste is subjective for key lime pie. Some like it sweeter, some like it more tart. This place's pie is more on the sweeter side. Still delicious, I prefer it a little sweeter than tart. Would go back