They have the best ice cream! They make it all there, everything is fresh and tasty! The rum raisin was my favorite!
1 - 10 of 254 reviews
The service was friendly and engaging, the offerings were amazing! This is a great place to stop by for a special treat or for taking out a treat for later!
Cookies and fudge were very good! Cookies are huge so plan on sharing! Staff was very friendly and gave us a good size sample of their fudge.
This place makes a range of excellent looking sweet fare on the premises. My husband and I had ice cream there twice. The selections were tasty and the portions were generous. There is very limited seating...but you can take your choice out to enjoy while...More
Our son in law is a chef so our standards are probably higher than most people's regarding quality because we have been spoiled. His key lime pie is the best but Mattheessen's is a close second. We have tried key lime pies throughout Key West...More
So the first time it was the giant chocolate chip cookie. It called to us from the window so we had to give it a go. It was wonderful.... Then we dropped by for ice cream. We know ice cream pretty well in New England....More
A cool, tart, sweet treat. Just pure deliciousness conveniently on a stick. The other treats in the shop were very enticing, but we were stuffed before we even walked in, so the pie was a stretch, but a must. We ate a lot of plain...More