A nice little find for delicious pizza! Not overly greasy, not expensive, or overly saucey - pure pizza!
1 - 10 of 46 reviews
I lived across the street for 7 years before giving Ernie’s a try. Now I’ve been several times. Quite honestly, I go only because there aren’t many other options nearby (Dayton Street would be a rival but the prices are ridiculous and the service is...More
Growing up in NEW HAVEN (Westville) we had it made as kids, our family always phoned in an order to EARNIES for " All MOOZ, half pepperoni" and another "All MOOZ and sausage" To this day even though most of the family has relocated elsewhere...More
Ernie's has been our family's favorite pizza place for many many years. It is easily as good as the more famous New Haven pizza restaurants and much easier to get into. They are nowhere as well known as they should be but maybe that is...More
My favorite new Haven style pizza! Whenever I'm away, I always come back home craving this this crust crispy deliciousness. And if you're lucky, they give you a tootsie pop as you leave
Been a fan for years. Great for take out or eat in. Don't expect a 20 minute pizza on weekends, expect a quality pizza, that's why if eating in, call ahead. Quality takes time and each pizza has the personal touch of the one and...More
There truly are no words for how much I adore/crave/dream about Ernie's pizza! Not initially from CT, it took me years to come around to the thin-crusted, brick oven-style New Haven is known for and this one leaves the Wooster Street institutions in their dust!...More
I love good pizza. I have lived in the New Haven area for almost 60 years and get pizza at least a couple times a month.I have been going to Ernie's since they opened 45 years ago, along with others like Zuppardi's, Pepes, Modern, Roseland,...More
Best New Haven Pizza, love it better than Modern. It is more flavorful and consistent. Sausage pie is my favorite. Give them a try if you are in westville.
A cousin of mine has brought us here several times, and it's become a real 'go to' for us since moving to Woodbridge. Being from Brooklyn, NY, I'm a bit of a pizza snob, so we're happy to have found this little gem.