The local say this is the spot, low key, very nice, and oh that Lamb Shank! Sat outside on covered patio, nice spot
1 - 10 of 351 reviews
Cool place right in old Mystic. Cozy, quaint, and clean. This is right up there with the better places to go. If you want unique, you have to try the Hot Rocks dishes. You simply will not find that anywhere, and you will not be...More
I was a steady customer many years ago and this revisit reminded me how good this place is. It was a busy night with folks sitting outside as well as inside. A nice overall feeling to this place with the old stone walls and overall...More
I had been to Anthony J’s for lunch, and while very good, I had no idea dinner would be as impressive as ours was last night. I had the best eggplant parm I have had - not breaded and fried, but layered with cheese and...More
A cozy, welcoming atmosphere with very good food, super happy hour menu. A favorite with the local crowd. Small bar, Mytic's version of "Cheers".
Just came back from another consistent dinner at AJ’s. So lucky to have such proximity to a great restaurant. I had the swordfish special but most dishes are very solid.
Quaint restaurant, they utilize every available space. Cute bar area, seating is very close to other customers, but the food is delicious, and lovely wine and beer options
We have been coming to Mystic the same weekend for years and AJ's has been my favorite place. This year it was a disappointment. From service to food was mediocre. Order the stone dish without calamari, it came loaded with it. Waitress offered to take...More
We had several new restaurants to try in Mystic and this was one of them. It's small and cozy, perfect for a cold winter night. The food was delicious, great choice of entrees.
This is our favorite Italian restaurant in Mystic. It's small and intimate if you sit to the right of the bar. The service is friendly and spot on. You can't go wrong with any of the meals, but you might have to wait for a...More