I absolutely love the food the flavor the atmosphere and the customer service all go hand in hand I wouldn't suggest any other pizza place over Mary's! They also have the absolute best salad dressing and fresh salads in town
1 - 10 of 29 reviews
Always go to my old reliable and favorite order; pepperoni and sausage pizza with wings. Make sure to get the thick crust. This way you have substance. The quality of the pizza is excellent along with the wings. I ordered it to go and they...More
With the demise of RoundTable/TerraVino/Joey's, Mary's Pizza Kitchen is Sebastopol's best pizza, at least if you like a thicker crust. Mary's is also the locals' choice for dinner, beating out Fandee's with a much stronger menu and free bread at the table If you get...More
I get the thick crust and it's excellent. Usually order pepperoni and sausage with extra pizza sauce and it's delicious. Just an old fashioned pizza guy, not looking for anything fancy. Give me a great pepperoni and sausage pizza, with plenty of mozzarella and great...More
We had a quick lunch here choosing the half-sandwich and salad, and the soup and salad. All was fresh and served quickly. Good quality food and fast service.
I absolutely love Mary's Pizza Shack. The Mary's Salad is excellent, my favorite salad anywhere. The homemade dressings are so good, the best is ranch, but the Italian and bleu cheese are quite tasty too. The bread sticks and french bread are amazing. The staff...More
Mary's has several locations in Sonoma County and the problem might be unique to Sebastopol, but our group waited about 40-minutes from being seated until our food arrived on an uncrowded Tuesday evening. As the pleasant waitress explained, the many takeout orders slow down the...More
Pizza and pastas as well as great salads and soups. Specials every day and wonderful location and staff. Try their Calamari fried lightly with a meat sauce side for dipping.
I must have eaten here over 100 times. The best pizza. We love their salads as well. Great family environment. Fair prices. They all seem to take great pride in the food. Very helpful wait staff as well