The ice cream is good with many unique flavors to choose from. Kind of pricey. For four of us it was $26. If you do go ask for a shot of espresso over your ice cream, it is quite good and very unique.
1 - 10 of 152 reviews
The ice cream tastes homemade. They have very unique choices. I don't normally eat a lot of ice cream, so I just got a kids size. But my friends got a regular size and they said it excellent. The little house it's at is very...More
Ice cream was like homemade and very good, but not many flavors to choose from. We thought the staff was great. We had the toasted marshmallow topping and it was very good. Price was high, but we would come here again for sure. Don't miss...More
Dad used to crank up the ice cream maker, and we loved to get the paddles fresh from the batch when he said it was finally ready. Penny Ice Cream uses freshly made base flavored with everything from New Orleans Coffee to Black Tea Peach...More
This is a fun little place, with some unique choices of ice cream that you can't get elsewhere. I would try it if you are looking for something unique. However, I think the amount of ice cream you get for the price makes it pricey....More
The Penny Ice Creamery is a must-stop in Santa Cruz. There is frequently a steady line out the door on the weekends, which is always a good sign! It is definitely worth the wait! They make all of their ice cream there and their home...More
Delightful choices and scrumptious ice cream! Charming and welcoming. Located in the heart of Santa Cruz.
This is really yummy and creative Ice creamery. They make all of there ice cream from scratch and offer the most unique and creative flavors. The staff even makes there whipped cream, in small patches, and waffles from scratch -- the fresh whipped cream is...More
Absolutely delicious, innovative, surprising flavors. Long lines for a reason, good for them! Even the ice cream cones are to die for......