This is my favorite Italian in the fox valley. It tastes so fresh and I love that it isn't a chain. If you haven't tried it yet you need to.
1 - 10 of 793 reviews
Am a business traveler and upon recommendation went here for dinner twice in one week. Food and service are great however location and ambience average. Staff very friendly. Place is excessively noisy when busy making conversation difficult. There can be excessive wait times and bar...More
I have been going to Carmella's on a regular basis since they opened several years ago. I love this restaurant. The last visit we received less than satisfactory service. The visit was my wife and I along with another couple celebrating our birthdays. We do...More
We went for an early dinner and were seated immediately. We shared a crispy calamari appetizer which was lightly breaded and fried to perfection. All of our entrees were generously portioned and delicious. I would definitely eat here again.
The owners share their passion for this restaurant with their customers. Recipes have been passed down through generations. Everything we have had here is excellent. While attending a retirement party, the scallops were the best I've ever had and the presentation was unreal. Do not...More
There is just nothing bad you can say about Carmellas... the food is outstanding, the wine selection is unique and delicious and the service is superb. We've gone here several times and every experience is amazing. Best place in Appleton
This is a very nice place to go if you are wanting to celebrate a friend's birthday, impress a client or have a special occasion. The food is excellent, and the menu is creative. I'm not a big wine drinker, but the pinot grigio I...More
It was a nice surprise to find such fine dining in Appleton. Carmella's was everything and more starting off with a good bottle of wine, and continuing on to the best pasta we have ever had possible in the world. It was cooked al dente...More