The wait for a table was about 45 minutes but the menu had a big selection. Spaghetti was good and staff was friendly
1 - 10 of 836 reviews
We've been here a few times and have never been disappointed. We each had a soup (perfect for a cold, windy day), and a main entree. Everything was excellent. Save room for dessert (I got a box for the rest of my entree), they were...More
As a hearing aid person, the acoustics are terrible. I could not hear the folks at my table in a simple conversation. I mentioned it to mgt and the response was people like the noisy atmosphere, Needless to say, I have not returned since.
Everything is awesome! Very attentive, wine list is great, this is by far my favorite restaurant in Appleton. I usually get the scallops and risotto. It's so good! The night we went most recent, it was cold and very windy. They sat us next to...More
What a great find! I was visiting Appleton for work and found Carmella’s was well-reviewed. My coworker and I enjoyed a delicious meal and outstanding service. He had the tomato bisque and chicken Marsala. I had the pappardelle with chicken and mushrooms in an Asiago...More
Carmella's is our go-to place for a nice Italian dinner. The risotto is the best! There isn't anything on the menu that isn't good. Be prepared to wait, it is always busy but worth the few minutes you may need to wait.
The food here is always delicious. The wait is what keeps me from coming more. They only take reservations for 6 or more. So if you have less expect a long wait during the dinner hour. If you look around the restaurant it is obvious...More
One of our favorite dining establishments in the Fox Cities. Like having a casual lunch here with family and friends. Great food. Friendly people