We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
There are only two restaurants on Water Island. Heidi's and Dingy's. Dingy's is on the beach. Reviews are great on both, but I decided to try Heidis even though I was at the beach all day. Heidi's overlooks the ocean. I drove up the hill...in our golf cart, stopped by the side of the road, loved the view, but immediately thought I was going to hate it. Its not a restaurant, its a food truck, but awesome tables and view. My 14 year old daughter said it was the best burger she ever had, which I thought was strange because she's a complainer. And I loved the fish tacos. She toasted the tortilla, and used some great spices. So, we went to the beach, and I was pretty sure I was going to get something at Dingy's in the afternoon, but I kept craving the fish tacos again, and my daughter really wanted another burger, so we went back to Heidis.. Twice in one day. It was really good.More
We visited Heidi’s for lunch on our day trip to Water Island. Food and drinks were great, but the view was unbeatable!!!!! We sat and talked to all the others eating lunch, everyone was so friendly. We had hot dogs, burgers and sausages. They had...a full bar as well!More
Heidi’s is no longer on the beach. She now has a place up the hill on Water Island. We stopped there for Sunday brunch. A limited menu but the food was good and it is a lovely view overlooking Crown Bay/Elephant Bay.
Stopped by while we were on our charter sailing trip. The fish tacos were recommended to us by locals...and now we recommend them to you !!! Combine with a Pain Killer and you are set for a nice lunch.
We stayed on Water Island and had lunch at Heidi's twice. We had the fish tacos, salmon slider special and a big vegetable salad. Everything was delicious and probably tasted even better given we were in swimsuit right on the beach!
They had drink specials...every day and you can't really beat the $5 rum punches.
I got stung by a wasp while walking down to the beach and the server at Heidi's was very kind and gave me a bag of ice when I asked for it. She scrounged around and found a bag to fill with the ice. That and a rum punch literally took the pain away!
I wish we had gone back one more time to try a cheeseburger - they looked amazing!More
Staying on Water Island we frequented Heidi’s nearly daily on both our trips!
Daytime at the beach bar with great cocktails and food! The tacos are amazing but I dream about the polish sausage! It’s so good, you must try it! I tried to recreate...several of the dishes at home and no where near as good.
We checked out movie on the beach, bingo and Saturday night dinner too - all perfect! Our dinners at dinner night we super yummy! Mmmm!!More