If you haven't had the cheesecake here, do it... now! It's made in-house and is beyond words. Amazing texture, creaminess and taste. A++
1 - 10 of 155 reviews
Most popular, good staff, good food and great desserts. Fabulous views. And if you are stying at Mayne Island resort you can get take out. Yum Yum
My wife an I stayed at the Mayne Island Resort in May, 2017. We had lunch at the Bennett Bay Bistro and everything was great. Both the service and food was very good. We had the fish and chips and the BLT. They were excellent....More
Probably the best restaurant on the island. A bit on the too-pricey side but the food and service were very good. At least the portions were sizable. Everything was clean and classy so it was a nice experience.
Dave & Colleen operate an amazing kitchen - we ended up eating there every meal during our stay at Mayne Island Resort as the menu had a wonderful selection, the servers were friendly and attentive and the food was so delicious!
We visited the Bennett Bay Bistro a couple of times but we chose to visit a bakery and take out food from the grocery store after. It is okay but the staff do not appear to be happy and in one instance there was a...More
It is a bistro, I think some of the reviewers expect too much. Had lunch, dinner, drinks at the bar and takeout. The prawns with lime first rate, the soups homemade delicious and clearly labled. The staff were fun, and enjoyed chatting at the bar...More
Dave, the chef, has an extraordinary gift of bringing great flavors to a dinner menu. We tried several items and were so delighted with all the amazing tasty combinations, it was a given we would come back the second night to experience another whole dinner...More