We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviews pappardelle short ribs pasta grapefruit margarita lump crab homemade ricotta apple crisp ribeye calamari appetizer cheesecake duck confit bread mahi mahi rooftop garden st john make reservations by the glass
Be sure to make reservations - seafood is over the top but you have to order a pasta dish. Calamari is fresh and the salads are large enough to share. Save room for dessert since the bread pudding and the apple crisp were amazing.
Delish! Make a reservation! Worth every penny. We had the house made Ricotta for starters, an excellent steak, fingerling potatoes and asparagus for the main course and was sadly too full for dessert which looked Amazing.
This was our second time dining at Extra Virgin Bistro and it was as good as I remembered. Servers are equally friendly and attentive, leaving you to never having to look for someone when something was needed at the table. The quality of the food...is top notch, with much of the food on the menu sourced locally. The menu is diverse including meat, fresh seafood, pasta and vegetarian dishes meaning there is something for everyone here. Creative cocktails and a nice wine list round out the menu. Very enjoyable!More
Yes that was the name of an actually drink they had and it was amazing. Everything was so good at this place including the ambience! Drinks were lovely and the short rib was UNBELIEVABLE. I couldn’t finish it but took it back to my hotel...to make nachos with later. Make sure to try the gnocchi too, I almost licked the plate! Staff was lovely and we had a great time!More
Amazing food, exquisite service, and top notch food! We had the best dinner at Extra Virgin. The pappardelle, ricotta, sausage and gnocchi, and fresh catch of the day were all out of this world. The kale Caesar was one of the best I’ve had. We...were too full to try any dessert, but I’m sure the bread pudding was to die for! Definitely will return and recommend to anyone!More
The short rib entree was virtually all fat. I exchanged plates with my wife and she agreed. I ordered the short rib entree based on its popularity at this restaurant but clearly inconsistent performance will lose customers. It was May 14th, a busy Friday. Our...server checked with us after 15-20 minutes after which I said I only want a check at this point and don’t bother with compensation. Our salad was exceptional, much better than the short rib.More
I was in the USVI at the very end of July and Extra Virgin had in-restaurant dining. The USVI closed to travel a couple of weeks later because of a bump in Covid cases. I’d suggest giving the restaurant a call. They’re... More
I was in the USVI at the very end of July and Extra Virgin had in-restaurant dining. The USVI closed to travel a couple of weeks later because of a bump in Covid cases. I’d suggest giving the restaurant a call. They’re popular, so you’ll definitely want reservations if they’re open.
Response from RichardJulieW | Reviewed this property |
I do not recall, however it was a nine year old who recommended this restaurant. He said the cheese ravioli was his favorite. The menu changes everyday, depending on what the chef has on hand...check them out on their... More
I do not recall, however it was a nine year old who recommended this restaurant. He said the cheese ravioli was his favorite. The menu changes everyday, depending on what the chef has on hand...check them out on their website. If you have a couple of kiddos, I would think they would let you split a meal.