We dropped by every single one of the 4 days we were here. The smallest cup comes generously heaped with 2 scoops. Standouts for me were the yogurt ice creams, especially the yogurt amarena and dulce de leche combo.
Recommended hunting out at the top (higher) end of the main street leading to the church. There are unusual flavours worth trying here, including rice-pudding and cheese cake ice-cream, all fabulous. One generous scoop would set you back 1.90E in August 2016.