We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
No visit to Sag Harbour would be complete without a visit to the American Hotel, eat if you can - but booking is a must. Drinks at the bar will give you a sence of the traditional athmospher and you will be well looked after...More
This review is of the restaurant attached to this hotel. We were recommended this by a local for our first trip to Sag Harbour. We arrived very late for lunch but the staff were very good and we managed to have a terrific meal. Pretty...More
We went as a group and this place never disappoints. The staff is very knowledgeable yet friendly. The food is excellent and priced accordingly... I was delighted with the presentation, timely service and quality. Overall it’s very very nice.
I've been frequenting this restaurant for years. The food has improved recently, and the service is always very professional. So sad, though, that the beloved maitre d', Richard, is no longer with them.
My wife & I stayed at the American Hotel, having heard rave reviews about it. If you want to know what a first class Hotel was like in 1894, book a room and step back in history. If you are expecting anything even near a...More