In general, I would prefer to stay off Island as you can get much better rates with the same amenitites. You have to remember this is a "vintage" hotel on a vintage island. The rooms are rather small but they are nice clean rooms. They...More
"Rooms overlooking the pool don't have a window to the outdoors so rooms are dark"
"we were on the 2nd floor next to the public balcony- good place to sit and people watch"
"I have read reviews that the rooms around the pool can be noisy, ours was on the front facing Main street..."