We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Pigeon Cay Beach Club

Save
Share
Pigeon Cay General Delivery to Arthurs Town Cat Island
COVID-19 update: See the added health and safety measures this property is taking.Read more
Expedia.com
Hotels.com
Orbitz.com
Travelocity
Booking.com
CheapTickets
View all 7 deals
Prices are provided by our partners, and reflect nightly room rates, including all taxes and fees known to our partners. Please see our partners for more details.
Payments made by partners impact the order of prices displayed. Room types may vary.
traveler_photos_ffffe986 (433)
360
album_panoramas (9)
room_amp_suite (289)
Payments made by partners impact the order of prices displayed. Room types may vary.

About

#5 of 12 hotels in Cat Island
Location
Cleanliness
Service
Value
Pigeon Cay Beach Club consists of 8 Cottages on a 3 mile white Sand Beach. We are located in the Northern end of Cat Island, 20 miles North of New Bight airport (TBI) 15miles from Arthurs Town Airport (ATC) Private, Small, Intimate. Come Gaze at the Stars, Listen to the Sea, Hear the Birds Sings, Come Enjoy the Peace at Pigeon Cay
Read more
Full view
Property amenities
hotel_amenity_free_parking
amenity_free_internet_title_ad3
hotel_amenity_bar_lounge
hotel_amenity_beach
hotel_amenity_badminton
hotel_amenity_babysitting
hotel_amenity_books_dvds_music_for_children
amenity_pets_allowed_title_ad3
hotel_amenity_wifi
hotel_amenity_coffee_shop
hotel_amenity_restaurant
hotel_amenity_breakfast_available
hotel_amenity_breakfast_in_the_room
hotel_amenity_complimentary_instant_cofffee
hotel_amenity_complimentary_tea
hotel_amenity_outdoor_dining_area
hotel_amenity_special_diet_menus
hotel_amenity_wine_champagne
hotel_amenity_bicycles_available
hotel_amenity_canoeing
hotel_amenity_diving
hotel_amenity_hiking
hotel_amenity_snorkeling
hotel_amenity_fishing
hotel_amenity_patio
hotel_amenity_walking_tours
amenity_children_activities_title_ad3
hotel_amenity_highchairs_available
hotel_amenity_car_hire
hotel_amenity_taxi_service
hotel_amenity_photo_copier_fax_in_business_center
hotel_amenity_couples_massage
hotel_amenity_massage
hotel_amenity_open_air_bath
hotel_amenity_24_hour_security
hotel_amenity_bbq_facilities
hotel_amenity_baggage_storage
hotel_amenity_gift_shop
hotel_amenity_mosquito_net
hotel_amenity_non_smoking_hotel
hotel_amenity_outdoor_fireplace
hotel_amenity_outdoor_furniture
hotel_amenity_picnic_area
hotel_amenity_sun_deck
hotel_amenity_sun_terrace
hotel_amenity_sun_umbrellas
hotel_amenity_first_aid_kit
hotel_amenity_umbrella
hotel_amenity_express_check_in_check_out
hotel_amenity_private_check_in_check_out
Show more
Room features
hotel_amenity_allergy_free_room
hotel_amenity_blackout_curtains
hotel_amenity_air_conditioning
hotel_amenity_private_beach
hotel_amenity_additional_bathroom
hotel_amenity_coffee_tea_maker
hotel_amenity_cable_satellite_tv
hotel_amenity_walk_in_shower
hotel_amenity_desk
hotel_amenity_dining_area
hotel_amenity_housekeeping
hotel_amenity_private_balcony
hotel_amenity_safe
hotel_amenity_seating_area
hotel_amenity_sofa
hotel_amenity_wardrobe_closet
hotel_amenity_bottled_water
hotel_amenity_laptop_safe
hotel_amenity_private_bathrooms
hotel_amenity_tile_marble_floor
hotel_amenity_wake_up_service_alarm_clock
hotel_amenity_kitchenette
hotel_amenity_microwave
hotel_amenity_oven
hotel_amenity_refrigerator
hotel_amenity_stovetop
hotel_amenity_electric_kettle
hotel_amenity_kitchenware
hotel_amenity_complimentary_toiletries
hotel_amenity_hair_dryer
Show more
Room types
hotel_amenity_ocean_view
Good to know
HOTEL CLASS
HOTEL STYLE
hotel_style_tag_5297
hotel_style_tag_16551
Languages Spoken
hotel_amenity_english
212Reviews12Q+A56Room tips
Traveller rating
  • 186
  • 19
  • 1
  • 4
  • 2
Time of year
Traveller type
Language
  • More
Selected filters
  • Filter
  • English
Popular mentions
TTexasTom wrote a review May 2021
Fort Worth, Texas184 contributions43 helpful votes
+1
Pigeon Cay Beach Club never disappoints. This was my 7th stay at PCBC so that in itself speaks to how much I love this place. Leslie and Ned are great to work with in planning your trip and taking care of you while you are there with a quiet non-intrusive hospitality. This is the most beautiful beach anywhere. The amenities are free and accessible (kayaks, body boards, hammocks, snorkel gear, lounge chairs and umbrellas). Products used are eco friendly. If you need to just unwind and chill with no distractions, this is the place. Plenty of great places to visit and incredible eat near by. Or just relax at the honors tiki bar or go for a stroll on the scenic soft powder white sandy beach that is your front yard. All cottages are waterfront where the waves will lull you to sleep at night. Each cottage has porch with table and chairs to sit outside to enjoy a meal or some drinks between sessions on the beach. Not enough words to fully describe the experience. Come see for yourself!
Read more
Date of stay: May 2021Trip type: Travelled solo
Room Tip: Cat Island is pretty remote. There are several local folks who rent vehicles, I recommend Danny...
See more room tips
Helpful
Share
Joel S wrote a review May 2021
6 contributions1 helpful vote
We have been coming back here for years. Ned and Lesley are great hosts and it's been wonderful to watch the boys grow up over the years. This is a remote beach location with pretty great lodging. We had another wonderful stay and Ned's cooking skills are pretty amazing. If you're looking for seclusion and a beautiful white sand beach that you can have all to yourself This Is The Place!
Read more
Date of stay: April 2021
Location
Service
userrating.prompt.190
Helpful
Share
Response from Leslie Kennedy, Owner at Pigeon Cay Beach Club
Responded 4 weeks ago
Commander.....always apleasure to have the two of you return to PCBC I so enjoy our conversations at the Beach Bar and beyond.... happy you can travel again and fly..Happy times!
Read more
Elizabeth M wrote a review May 2021
Northampton, Massachusetts18 contributions13 helpful votes
My boyfriend and I had an excellent stay at Pigeon Cay Beach Resort. Pre-trip communication was top notch with Leslie replying to all my emails within a few hours. Both her and Ned were also easily available during our stay to answer any questions. Getting to Cat Island is an adventure all in itself and when our plans changed at the last minute due to COVID testing protocols and a delayed flight, Leslie came to the rescue and was able to book us last minute on a charter flight on BAM charter airlines. The location and accommodations are perfect, we stayed in the Little House which was feet from the beautiful white sand beach. Every morning we enjoyed coffee in the Adirondack chairs facing the turquoise waters. We felt like we had the whole beach to ourselves, as we rarely saw more than one or two other guests at a time on the beach (Not counting the owner's friendly and adorable dogs who would come and say hi every day) Pigeon Cay Beach Resort is a hidden gem, I am already planning my trip back! Thank-you Leslie and Ned!
Read more
Date of stay: April 2021
Helpful
Share
Response from Leslie Kennedy, Owner at Pigeon Cay Beach Club
Responded 4 weeks ago
Hi It was great to meet you both and have you share Pigeon Cay and Cat Island, we look forward to your return. Best to you both!
Read more
Ronald O wrote a review Apr 2021
1 contribution
We have been coming back for years - the owners, Ned and Leslie have built this little rustic paradise and are wonderful and thoughtful hosts. They bent over backwards to help us with travel and car arrangements and get the balance we want with housekeeping and meals and our desire to do things on our own. We love shopping at the island stores and making our own meals but also love when Ned cooks or when we go out and get a bite to eat at some of the other island spots. Cat Island is as authentic an out Island experience as it gets, it is rustic, remote, and devoid of annoying tourist throngs looking to swim with pigs, stuff their faces with food and drink, and moan about how Disneyland is better.
Read more
Date of stay: April 2021
Location
Cleanliness
Service
Room Tip: There are only 8 cottages - if you need a big resort stay on Nassau.
See more room tips
Helpful
Share
Response from Leslie Kennedy, Owner at Pigeon Cay Beach Club
Responded 4 weeks ago
It was so great to have you return back "home" to the beach. Happy you were able to share our little piece of Paridese with S&K. Miss our morning coffee sessions. All the best!
Read more
Heather B wrote a review Apr 2021
Seattle, Washington28 contributions4 helpful votes
The Pigeon Cay beach is beautiful and secluded. We'd been told this was an amazing resort (grass roots, but great location). We stayed in a Yurt. It was a relatively nice yurt on the beach. HOWEVER, the owner's dog bit my boyfriend in the leg and it started to bleed. They did not say sorry. There was nothing to eat or any spices in yurt. We asked if we could get something to eat. The owner went and came back with a few bean burritos and some wine - which was nice. HOWEVER, we lost water the last 2 days and they could not fix it. We couldn't shower or use toilettes unless we put a huge vat of drinking water down drain. The night before we left, Ned - the owner - literally got mad at us as we had not 'met' with him to discuss the real situation at Cat Island. He was dirty, smoking and just walked in our place. He badmouthed the wonderful neighbors we met (!) who were the highlight of our stay, charged us $300 for a room he quoted me at $220 and then said I was wrong (we got the $220), charged us $75 for the 'nice dinner', never apologized or offered anything after his dog bit my boyfriend. He even got upset that we didn't go through him to rent our car. It's obvious they upsell everything. Even without water, he still charged us full rate. We will NOT be back. They also tried to get us to "invest" with him. The whole thing seemed very dodgy and unsafe. It's sad that this place gives such a bad taste to such an amazing Island.
Read more
Date of stay: April 2021
Helpful
Share
Response from Leslie Kennedy, Owner at Pigeon Cay Beach Club
Responded 15 Apr 2021
Sorry you were not Happy and we could not accomodate you at the Club as we were full with HAPPY GUESTS. WHEN YOU CALLED AT THE LAST MINUTE YOU LET US KNOW YOU NEEDED SOME SPACE AND TO GET SOME RELIEF FROM YOUR SMALL BOAT, WE WERE HAPPY TO ACCOMODATE YOU AT THE ROUND HOUSE, A LOVELY TWO BEDROOM TWO BATH PRIVATE HOME. You failed to metion that you had a large dog, we are lovers of animals, and welcome pets,with notice. Sorry your dog was aggressive to my mellow dogs. We also arrange a rental car for you with a local place that your Boat Captain could conviently Drop you at the dock and an easy walk to her establishment, I belived she picked you up at the dock and you were on your way, as We do not rent cars we SUPPORT our local bussiness. The Round House has a 5000 gallon water tank that was full, ample water supply for your short stay, perhaps a bit to much Laudry was done, for you to return to your Boat, we did bring you 5, Five gallons jugs of water for your last day to have on hand , Living on an Island and you living on a Boat you know have to go into Port to resupply as we, either need a good rain from Mother Nature to resupply the water cistern or order water by the Truck load to resupply the water cistern we had niether with short notice. and being Easter Monday in the Bahamas it was a Holiday Dinner, Chicken, Burrittos, Tomatoes, Veggies, Cucumber and Apple Salad, for the two of you $50 was Delivered to you with a Bottle of Red Wine $28 BTW There are No Yurts on the Island Hope the rest of your sailing around the Islands goes smoothly
Read more
Previous
123456
PRICE RANGE
US$223 - US$277 (Based on Average Rates for a Standard Room)
ALSO KNOWN AS
pigeon cay beach club hotel cat island
LOCATION
CaribbeanBahamasOut IslandsCat Island
NUMBER OF ROOMS
8
Is This Your Tripadvisor Listing?

Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.

Claim Your Listing