Oops...my first sentence should read ...do NOT allow you to bring....sorry for the mistake...makes a big difference!
Most restaurants, including Wagon Wheel, do now allow you to bring your own wine, etc. I think San Juan is a "dry county" as are most in Utah, because of the Mormon influence. Wagon Wheel is pretty casual, so i suppose you could bring wine in an opaque water bottle/thermos, as long as you were discreet. Very few restaruants serve alcohol. But, the pizza and people make it worth the trip to Wagon Wheel..
Get quick answers from Wagon Wheel Pizza staff and past visitors.