Yes here at the Clam Bake we do take reservations, during the summer months you would be fine just to walk in, but from December through April I do think it's best to call and make a reservation because we get really busy..Hope you visit us soon.
We went off season and there was no reason to make a reservation. Their website does mention reservations in a contact form but it is something you submit and I believe more suited if you wanted tooo plan a party there. Why not just give then a call and ask. They seem like reasonable people and most likely will accommodate you. Here is their number 239 482 1930
Was there in August, happened to be nearby (visiting a Citrus Juice producer) and found online. Probably arrived just after the lunch crowd so was not busy and no reservations were necessary. Spoke w/ manager and he was a New England transplant - most of his business seems like locals as the restaurant is not near any tourist havens.
I would guess not; it's too casual a place for that. But if you're interested, call them. We've been there once, for lunch, and I liked it very much. Have not eaten dinner there. I assume they do quite a good business.
Get quick answers from Clam Bake staff and past visitors.