Approx. how many guests do you think can fit inside this church for a ceremony?
Also, you could contact the church or Varenna and ask. There is a monastery down the street a short ways on the lake which would be a beautiful venue.
A lot. Have you been to Varenna or Lake Como? I wasn't that impressed with this church. There are prettier churches and venues. I have spent a lot of time in Southern Tuscany which has some very pretty churches and venues.
I agree. About 200, maybe more. The church is lovely, but not spectacular. Its simplicity touched me. As I recall, there is one more modern detail above the altar that seems out of place with the honest and local simplicity of its romanesque details. After the ceremony you might convince several local eateries to combine forces and set you part on the part of the square apart from traffic, OR if you want upscale, speak to the garden which is closest to the church, they can handle a crowd, providing food, access to the garden, and indoor protection from a sudden cloudburst.
Get quick answers from Chiesa di San Giorgio staff and past visitors.