Best place is: CIGAR FACTORY.
Corner of 5th and 16th (crossroad).
They offer hand made cigars (thet roll them right there in the shop), as well as a variety of Cuban and Dominican cigars.
Bought one and they are very over priced and not that good to be honest.
I do not know. I drank margaritas at my all inclusive resort and do not smoke cigars anymore. I would do search on Google for "Best cigars 5th avenue playa del carmen" and see what happens? when in doubt, Google it!!!
I saw signs for cigars but am not knowledgeable about cigars.
Get quick answers from Calle Quinta Avenida staff and past visitors.