All Articles A spooky fall getaway in New Hope, Pennsylvania

A spooky fall getaway in New Hope, Pennsylvania

Laura Begley Bloom
By Laura Begley Bloom17 Oct 2024 9 minutes read
Fall foliage on trail outside New Hope
Exterior of waterfront Bucks County Playhouse amid fall trees
Close-up of a Jack O' Lantern
Trail outside New Hope (L); Bucks County Playhouse (C); Jack O' Lantern (R)
Image: Courtesy of Visit Bucks County (L, C); MASTER/Getty Images

Boo! Spooky season is out in full force, so we’re headed to one of the most haunted towns in the country: New Hope. Legendary paranormal investigator Adi-Kent Thomas Jeffrey—who founded Ghost Tours of New Hope 43 years ago—once famously said that there are “more ghosts per square mile in New Hope, Pennsylvania than anywhere else in the world.”

These days, those spirits are still hanging around this historic Bucks County town—and you’ll find them on just about every corner. “It is very difficult to pick a spot in New Hope that’s not haunted,” says Scott Randolph, who now manages Ghost Tours of New Hope with his wife, Carolyn. The Randolphs and their guides lead groups along the dark streets, lanterns in hand, telling spooky stories from the unknown (a lost hitchhiker) to the historic (Aaron Burr of Hamilton fame).

Left: Portrait of Randolph in blazer and tie; Center: Portrait of Gioconda wearing black jacket and glasses; Right: Portrait of Patterson smiling with glasses
Scott Randolph (L); Joe Gioconda (C); Melissa Patterson (R)

Looking for modern-day thrills? Hit up Joe Gioconda and his recently opened gallery-slash-shop, A Nightmare in New Hope. Gioconda is a lawyer by day who has been collecting horror movie props and costumes for about 20 years. You can see highlights from his collection (a dagger from the first Omen, an original prosthetic bust of Freddy Krueger) and buy movie memorabilia and oddities (spooky art, creepy dolls). Why New Hope? “Over time, I accumulated so many unique items from so many great films that a lot of my friends said, ‘This stuff really should be seen publicly,’” he says. “New Hope was the perfect place to open this gallery because it’s got a haunted feel and an incredible paranormal history.”

But it’s not all about the spooky stuff. “New Hope has hundreds of years of history—all jam packed in one square mile or so,” says Gioconda. “In every building, every piece of land, every bar, every basement, there’s some story that goes back 300-plus years.” And then there’s the fall foliage that surrounds you. “Since we’re on the Delaware River, it’s scenic and very wooded, so you really get to see the colors,” says Randolph.

This is from The WeekEnder series: local insider guides for new destinations a short drive from New York City, delivered to your inbox twice a month. Sign up here!

Another thing going for New Hope: Its thriving LGBTQ+ community. “New Hope is like a hug, no matter who you are or what you are—it’s inclusive, you feel welcome,” says Melissa Patterson, president of New Hope Celebrates, which creates events and programming geared toward the LGBTQ+ community and its allies. Patterson met her wife at a bar in New Hope 21 years ago and moved to the area because of its welcoming vibe. “We call New Hope ‘the bubble’ because you feel safe here and can be exactly who you are.”

The town’s annual Pride celebration (held in May) brings people from around the country, but so does LGBTQ+ History Month in October. Throughout the month, there are events like a special performance of The Rocky Horror Picture Show at the Bucks County Playhouse and the High Heel Drag Race, when thousands descend to watch drag queens compete wearing three-inch stilettos. “It’s New Hope’s own Kentucky Derby because it’s a lot of fanfare for a 32-second race,” says Patterson.

So whether you’re chasing ghosts, collecting horror movie memorabilia, scoping out the changing leaves, or strutting in stilettos, New Hope offers the perfect fall escape. And with its warm embrace, it’s a place where anyone can feel right at home—even if that home happens to be haunted.

Where to stay

In New Hope, every street seems to have a ghost story—and so do most of the hotels. Here’s our shortlist of where to stay.

Red building situated on river and with autumn trees behind it
Exterior of Ghost Light Inn.
Image: beth r/Tripadvisor

For spook-seekers: Logan Inn

The oldest building in New Hope has been given a modern overhaul—but it’s still got a rep for eerie experiences. “People used to avoid the Logan because it was notoriously haunted,” says Gioconda. “But now, that’s a selling point.” Do you dare stay in Room 6 (aka Emily’s Room)? Several guests have reported ghostly encounters.

For history buffs: Aaron Burr House

Antiques-filled rooms and hearty breakfasts will beam you back to the 1800s, but you might not be alone as you walk through the halls of this charming B&B where history and hauntings intertwine. Aaron Burr’s ghost has been spotted climbing the stairs and tugging at the clothing of guests.

Guest room with abstract art above the bed, a fireplace, and metal light fixture
Guest room at River House at Odettes.
Image: Management/Tripadvisor

For sweethearts: River House at Odette’s

Located right on the Delaware River, this loft-like hotel is named after Odette Myrtil, who used to run a bustling cabaret right on the site. It’s got a touch of paranormal intrigue, but the big appeal is its luxe setting with romantic fireside cocktails and stunning views.

For pet lovers: Ghost Light Inn

Right next to the Bucks County Playhouse is this 12-room inn. “It’s named after the old theater tradition of leaving a lantern lit on the stage to ward off ghosts and evil spirits,” says Randolph. Animal lovers appreciate the pet-friendly hospitality: The in-house restaurant, Stella, even offers a menu for pups.

Where to eat and drink

“I don’t think I’ve ever had a bad meal in New Hope,” says Randolph. And with our expert-approved list of where to go, you won’t either.

Left: Outdoor patio next to yellow-painted restaurant; Right: Salad with tomatoes
Patio (L) and salad (R) at Martine's.
Image: noreen f/Tripadvisor (L); Management/Tripadvisor (R)

Best breakfasts

Duck Soup Cafe - This lively place serves up all the breakfast classics, from blueberry pancakes to French toast. One reviewer summed it up best: “Excellent omelets with farm fresh eggs, an asparagus spear on a luscious side salad, great tea selection, and a waiter doing stand-up comedy. What more could one want?”

Karla’s Restaurant - Karla’s is a Sunday brunch institution, thanks to its decadent bites—think, creme brulee French toast, pork roll eggs Benedict with chipotle hollandaise, and a cappuccino martini that will start the day off right. “If anyone comes to visit me, I’ll take them here,” says Patterson. Her must-try? “They’ve got the best mac and cheese I’ve ever had in my life.” At brunch, it’s topped with a fried chicken breast.

Lunchtime

Martine’s - Whether you’re ordering a seared tuna salad, a crab cake sandwich, or a plate of fried green tomatoes with shrimp, bacon, and chipotle aioli, the menu here doesn’t miss—nor does the setting. “It’s a cute little spot right on the river with outdoor seating,” says Patterson.

Triumph Brewing Company - If craft beer is your thing, head to Triumph Brewing Company for a flight of local brews, a pub-style menu (rye pretzels with cheddar fondue, buttermilk chicken bao buns), and live music.

New Hope Ferry Market - Looking to grab a bite on the go or stock up on picnic supplies? Check out New Hope Ferry Market, a cool, renovated space with stands selling everything from corn dogs to BBQ to Japanese crêpes inspired by flowers. “It’s like a mini version of Reading Terminal Market in Philadelphia,” says Patterson.

Sushi boat and plate with sushi
Sushi at Nozomu.
Image: katherine524/Tripadvisor

Global flavors

Anzu Social - This Asian-fusion dining experience is the new kid on the block. The menu ranges from creative hand rolls (cornmeal-fried shrimp, scallops with chili crunch) to Singaporean shrimp satay and Korean fried chicken wings.

Nozomu - Opened by two best friends who saw a void in this town for Japanese food, Nozomu has quickly become a hot spot for sushi, sashimi, and specialty rolls inspired by the seasons. “It’s pretty new, and it’s really good,” says Patterson.

Casual bites

The Salt House - Set in a 1751 stone building with a wood-burning fireplace, the Salt House serves up locally sourced food and craft cocktails, alongside a bit of history (and perhaps a ghost or two). “It’s cozy inside and very haunted,” says Randolph. “They also have an outdoor patio so that people can sit outside.”

Spatola’s Pizza - It’s all about classic Italian flavors at this easygoing spot, where Randolph says you can’t go wrong with the chicken parm or the pizzas. “They also have plenty of options for vegetarians,” he says.

Left: Six-person table inside dimly lit restaurant with flowers on tables; Right: Pasta dish topped with tuna
Dining room (L) and pasta (R) at Zoubi.
Image: Management/Tripadvisor (L); Free Bridge R/Tripadvisor (R)

Date night

Zoubi - Randolph says this intimate restaurant with a romantic courtyard is “a secret hideaway that many people overlook—and it’s outstanding.” The inventive French-inspired dishes range from herb-crusted lamb lollipops to foie gras toast with rose wine jelly, pink peppercorn, and pickled grape.

Stella - Located in the Ghost Light Inn, Stella was named after the owner’s rescued one-eared pit bull. Dishes celebrate the region’s best farmers and food artisans, and the pretty riverside setting doesn’t hurt either. Reviewers rave about the salmon with lemon-parsley farro, asparagus, and crispy mushrooms.

Drinks

Nektar Wine Bar - Just across from the Bucks County Playhouse, Nektar is the ultimate pre-theater spot for a glass of wine, a pint of beer, or a dram of whiskey.

Havana - “It’s one of the most popular bars in town. It’s open air, right on Main Street, and has a really cool Cuban theme,” says Gioconda, who loves the mojitos. Rumor has it that Aaron Burr hid out upstairs after his duel with Alexander Hamilton.

The Cub Room - At the heart of New Hope’s LGBTQ+ scene, this tiny space is always full of life, whether you’re here for live music, DJ performances, drag shows, tea dances, or a casual night out.

What to do

Tours, farms, and the great outdoors

New Hope may be a small town, but it’s packed with outdoor beauty and a side of ghostly intrigue. Here are a few activities not to miss.

Person in black hooded cape holding lantern in cemetery at night
Cemetery tour with Ghost Tours of New Hope.
Image: Courtesy of Visit Bucks County

Ghost Tours of New Hope - For thrill-seekers looking to tap into the town’s haunted history, this tour company is the real deal. “We tell true stories and take you to the spots where those paranormal events took place,” says Randolph. Tours meet at Ferry and Main Streets and run through November, with extra dates in October. Be sure to bring a flashlight and wear sensible shoes—all the better to chase after any apparitions.

Van Sandt Covered Bridge - Just a couple miles outside town, this historic structure named after some of the area’s most prominent early settlers is perfect for a spine-tingling detour. “It’s also known as the ‘Cry Baby Bridge,’” says Gioconda. Some visitors report hearing the cries of a baby who supposedly died here.

Manoff Market Gardens - If you’re looking for a wholesome activity out in the fresh autumn air, head to this family-friendly spot where you can tap into the harvest season at its best—plucking apples straight from the orchard.

Solebury Orchards - You can also pick your own apples at this family-run farm, but the big appeal here is the market, which sells homemade applesauce, fruit bitters, and apple cider donuts that are famous in these parts.

Goat Hill Overlook in Lambertville - For panoramic views that stretch across the Delaware River, hike to Goat Hill Overlook in nearby Lambertville. The short-but-steep trail rewards you with sweeping vistas of the fall foliage on both sides of the river.

Arts and culture

New Hope isn’t just about scenic views and spooky encounters—it’s also a haven for artists, musicians, performers, and lots of history.

Exterior of three-story home with blue doors and shutters
Exterior of Parry Mansion.
Image: Management/Tripadvisor

Bucks County Playhouse - Built in a converted 18th-century mill, this playhouse puts on Broadway-level productions. “Whatever you see at the Bucks County Playhouse, it’s going to be really good,” says Randolph. And there’s some spooky action here, too: “There’s a theory that the running water from the old grist mill creates a magnetic grid that keeps spirit energy trapped,” says Gioconda.

New Hope Arts Center - Based in a pre-Revolutionary War theater, this space showcases emerging and established contemporary artists. “I’ve always been impressed with the diversity of talent in New Hope, and they show a lot of really great local artists,” says Gioconda. Plus, the building itself has stories of ghostly mischief that have fascinated visitors for years.

John & Peters Place - If you’re looking for live music with a laid-back, old-school vibe, John & Peters Place is a local institution. “It’s such a cool, divey place that keeps that classic New Hope feel,” says Patterson. “They also have great bar food with my favorite—tater tots.”

Parry Mansion - Dating back to 1784, this mansion gives visitors a glimpse into the life of Benjamin Parry, one of New Hope’s founding fathers, while sharing fascinating stories about the town’s early days. There are also free historic walking tours on weekends.

Shopping

New Hope’s independent shops are what gives the town its quirky charm. Spend your dollars here, and you’ll be joining the movement to “keep New Hope weird,” according to Gioconda.

Left: Conjuring nun exhibit; Right: Dracula portrait
Conjuring (L) and Halloween exhibit (R) at A Nightmare in New Hope.
Image: Courtesy of A Nightmare in New Hope

A Nightmare in New Hope - Step inside this eerie gallery, where Gioconda has curated a collection of horror movie memorabilia, including items like the Annabelle doll from The Conjuring and props and prosthetics from the movie Pet Cemetery. Plus, there are haunted dolls with red eyes and objects with paranormal histories (haunted Ouija board, anyone?), making it the perfect stop for fans of the strange and supernatural. “It’s creepy, but fascinating,” says Randolph.

The Creeper Gallery - The name of this store says it all. “It’s the kind of place where you’ll find haunted items, paranormal artifacts, and even shrunken heads,” says Gioconda.

Love Saves the Day - A New Hope staple, this kitschy vintage shop is a treasure trove of retro clothing, funky accessories, and one-of-a-kind gifts. “If you have never been to Love Saves the Day, you have to go,” says Patterson.

PlantHaus - Get creative at this new spot in town, where you can paint your own vase or planter while enjoying the lush atmosphere. “It’s perfect for a hands-on experience,” says Patterson.

Farley’s Bookshop - Read up on New Hope’s history at this independent bookstore, which stocks a carefully curated selection of new and used books (and has a few ghosts of its own floating around).

Laura Begley Bloom
Laura Begley Bloom is a travel expert and content strategist who writes for a wide range of magazines and websites and appears regularly on television outlets ranging from the Weather Channel to CNN. Journalism is part of Laura's heritage. Her great great grandfather was a Civil War correspondent for the Chicago Tribune. You can learn more about Laura on laurabegleybloom.com.