Of the islands I've been too (Aruba, St. Thomas), the service I received at Rose Hall was unparalleled. Though I'd gotten used to and expected the concept of "island time" to be the same for this stay as for others, the staff surprised me greatly with prompt and accurate service. This may have been a function of this being the Ritz-Carlton or the high vacancy rate (25%) but either way, I was very pleased. My boyfriend and I stayed for three nights and purchased an all-inclusive package. The dining options at the hotel were very good, though a longer stay may have been stretching the menus. I would recommend going to the White Witch restaurant for lunch, as the view is more impressive than the food. And I still have dreams about Boo Loos, a banana colada type frozen drink, that we consumed continuously on the beach. The rooms and the decor of most of this hotel were mediocre at best, I thought the bedding was actually below par in comfort. We did get a great deal on the room and the package so we weren't greatly disappointed. Despite all the good points about this hotel, I do think that it is only meant for a quiet getaway, not a long vacation. I am positive I would have been bored to tears if I had stayed for a full 6 nights.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC