We have been eating their pizza for years and it is clearly the best in town. Haven't tried much of other items. Stopped by tonight with the family and we all split an 18" pizza and a few salads. It's thin style and not too much sauce like the chain places. Like true New York pie!!! The decor is ok,... More

I gave this place 3 stars because my husband and son liked it. I, on the other hand, will never return. I ordered a greek salad. It came in a large bowl and, at first, I was psyched. However, as soon as my fork hit the bottom of the bowl, I was angry. They charged $7.95 for a very small... More

We came from the Northeast to live in St. Marys and there is so little restaurant choices in town..Never mind Italian or Pizza. There two pizza place in town, Papa's or Pizza Hut.. Papa's wins. Nice little family owned pizza place with ok pizza..

you won't go away hungry here... the eggplant is absolutely delicious and comes with a side of spaghetti...the marinara is fab... salad is generous with garlic bread too.... the service is outstanding...5 star all the way....

We decided to take in the movie Girl with the Dragon tatoo and this restaurant was recommended by the hotel. The food was fresh and authentic, unlike most pizza places. The crust on the pizza was the best we've ever had.

Excellent pizza, good value. My only recommendation (and this is universal, not just to this restaurant) is to put some conveniences in the Women's restroom... a hook on which to hang a purse as well as a coat hook would be great. Little things, easy to do, but makes the visit so much nicer when they are provided. On this... More

Papa Luigi's is the best pizza outside of NYC. It is to die for. The decor is beautiful, as the restaurant has been renovated after a small fire a few months ago. I love this place!

This is quite possibly the best pizza outside of NY. Great pit stop if you are road tripping on I-95 near the FL/GA border.