Recommended to me by the owners of the Wyo Motel. The absolute best Ribeye I have ever had. If you are passing through this area, this is a must stop.
First, the meal was awesome! One of the best Filet's I have ever eaten. It was cooked perfectly and offered a wonderful smokey flavor. The Béarnaise sauce was a dry package mix made with water, which in my opinion makes it no longer Béarnaise sauce…The creamed spinach was decadent! The prime rib was also cooked perfectly and very good. Now,... More
Decided to eat at this restaurant based on a local recommendation. We arrived and were met by a 1 hour + wait for a party of 4. We were finally seated and ordered upon being greeted by our server. The food came and it was average, nothing special. The service was poor as we did not get items requested and... More
Had one of the best steaks of my life - and that is a lot of steaks. Menu said it was a 14 oz New York strip, but it was at least 20 oz, cooked perfectly, seasoned perfectly. Just a great steak! Large perfectly cooked baked potato was very nice. Salad to start was okay - good blue cheese dressing.... More
Lots of food but a bit pricey. Nice atmosphere. Chicken pot pie and pork loin very good. Large portion of appetizers.
This was a very nice experience from the minute we walked in the door. The hostess was friendly and gave us a nice table over looking the dining room. Our server was efficient and friendly. Just don't order an onion with your martini. It came with a slice of red onion and we all had a grand laugh on that... More
Hot, cooked just right, great seasoning, served super fast. Way better than any chain as well! To bad they dont have one of these in Austin
We ate at all three top-rated restaurants in Buffalo and this one was the only good one. Our food was cooked properly, it was tasty, the service and ambiance were good, and the prices were reasonable. I'd come back here for sure.
I liked this place because of cozy, old fashioned feel...it ain't Morton's but for the locale, it was fun. Buffalo is a great little town
It wasn't bad... But definitely doesn't live up to the expectations that we were told about the place. It was obvious that there were lots of tripadvisor readers there with all the out of state plates in the parking lot. Bland and tasteless prime rib. Service was good. Just not worth the hype or the money spent. Wish we would... More
If you own or manage Winchester Steakhouse, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing