We stopped in during our 3 day stay in L.G. as the place reminded me of the Grand Traverse Pie Companies in Michigan. While their counter staff could use a little direction on cheerfulness and helpfulness, the pies could not have been better. I am always a little leery of crumb-top pies, having had more than a few that were... More

You would be crazy not to stop for pie here. We get them for holidays and afternoon sweet tooths! My favorite is the crumb apple, but my moms favorite is the 4 berry. What ever you choose, you won't be disappointed. Only issue: they do sell out everyday, so either call ahead or go early

Never disappointed with their pies. Always top quality. Every pie is made fresh. Great place to stop in and have a cup of coffee with your favorite piece of pie.

Our holiday visit to Timber Ridge is not tradition unless we get our Christmas pies from the Lake Geneva Pie Co. My husband and I get a fruit cobbler, my 15 year old son gets the French silk, and my 18 year old son gets the key lime pie. We look forward to the short drive from the resort. The... More

The Lake Geneva Pie Company is where I go when I want to bring something really special and super delicious to a party or gathering. Their classic Pecan Pies are always stellar....and the cocoanut cream pie rocks! Easy to get get to and free parking.

Anytime I have the luck of passing by I come home with 2 or 3 pies. I think it's one if my favorite places to get pie. Coconut pie that has coconut to die for. My other favorite is the blueberry crumb. Their pies aren't cheap, but you get what you pay for. Service is okay, nothing stands out. It... More

What can you say about the pies except they were exceptional. We stopped in the morning before going home and picked up some small pies and a frozen cherry pie for later enjoyment.

We found this place several years ago and have made a point to detour here whenever we are traveling in the area. We love the garbage and lakeshore crumb top pies but have not been disappointed with whatever we have tried. We have several times placed a order ahead and picked up frozen ones to take home.

Not that much of a selection if you just want one piece. Was hoping for lemon angel, but they had mostly fruit pies. Wasn't really that nice inside, had some strange people hanging out in there,. Would not go back