Great quality pizza in Shelter Cove. Must be popular with locals, because was busy on Fri night. Couple small tables & a few outside too. Loved the crust, good topping options. Chicken was dry, but everything else was perfect!

Great quality pizza in Shelter Cove. Must be popular with locals, because was busy on Fri night. Couple small tables & a few outside too. Loved the crust, good topping options. Chicken was dry, but everything else was perfect!
We go here at least once a month and the pizza is always ready on time, fresh, of the highest quality and filing. Restaurant offers take out and dine in eating and the place is immaculately clean.
Hello! Thank you for the review, however the Fish Tank Pizzeria closed November of 2012. You must be talking about the new pizzeria that is now at our old location.
More
They had many choices of toppings and crusts, including gluten free crust. Both of us agreed it was some of the best pizza we have had yet.
The restaurant was recommended by our inn manager as the only option available this particular evening. Arrived to find it closed for painting.
justin and all his friends! great at the best pizzas! can't go to shelter cove without justin being there! and good good food.//we all just love him
have had pizza here before. took long time to make....but was worth it. taking one star away because they werent open while we are here! closed on tue and wednesday?? disappointed.
Pizza was very good. They had a pear cider beverage that is out of this world. Great with the pizza. Very limited on restaurants around the area. This was very convient and the owner was nice and polite.
The only pizza place in a tiny town with only one road for access, a twisty-winding steep road through the mountains…one of just four restaurants in town…since there’s nowhere else to go, the pizza is probably not that great, right? Wrong!!
The pizza is just as good as at our preferred pizzerias at home. Service is friendly and accommodating. No...
More
Wonderful people. So friendly. Pizza is great. The all meat is delicious. Thanks for the complimentary bottle of champagne for our anniversary you guys are great. Can't wait to visit again
Hello! Thank you for the review, however the Fish Tank Pizzeria closed November of 2012. You must be talking about the new pizzeria that is now at our old location.
More
The pizza was okay. Not great; not bad. It was hot and we ate it with good wine on our balcony overlooking the pacific as the sun set. Really, who cares about the food?!
If you own or manage The Fish Tank Pizzeria, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing