Great pizza, funky "Woodstock" atmosphere, cute little al fresco area ideal for hanging out and/or watching the local scene.
Don't be misinformed by it's name - it is not your average pizza shop, although they have one in the front. However, once you get passed that, you will discover that it also has a very nice tavern-style restaurant that serves great food. The service couldn't be any better. They make great wings, but there are also options that are... More
his is a great place to eat in a hurry. I ate there when Imarrived as I was having a late lunch. service is quick and the portions are generous. I had a house salad, lettuce with onion, cucumber and some tiny bits of cheese and one slice of regular pizza. it satisfies my hunger but the salad was unremarkable... More
We live here. We eat their very good pizza all the time. It's the best place to sit outdoors and watch the world drive by. Yesterday we ordered the fried calamari for the first time. We order calamari a lot, all over the place. This is THE BEST CALAMARI we've had in years.
Tasty/spicy, cheesy and crisp. Very large cheese slices. Nice selection of smaller specialty slices. Good selection of bottled soft drinks. Expanded seating area is tastefully designed (although some of the art work is unappealing).
Being from the NY Metro area, we have been spolied by having access to the best pizza in the country. The Catskill Mountain Pizza pleasantly surprised us with the quality and tastiness of their pizza. The specialty pizzas are to be explored or add your own toppings---I recommend pancetta and banana peppers!! Fast and friendly customer service with outdoor seating... More
Was skeptical when I saw 'authentic' Italian pizza. However this little pizzeria delivered!! We really enjoyed the taste & thin crust. There was also a veggie option packed with tasty veg. Worth the visit.
I've been eating at this pizza place for 12 years. In the last few months so many things have been wrong. First of all, the department of health would be appalled to look in the back of the place. It's filthy. And the garbage receptacles in the front are always overfilled, so that dirty plates and napkins are spilling over.... More
If you own or manage Catskill Mountain Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing