It is not a restaurant - but an all-organic grocery. They have two tables and a bar counter inside, some more tables outside, and offer tasty muffin sandwiches and breakfast plates. The coffee is although not excellent and there is a bit too much ice in the smoothies. It is overall a very pleasant breakfast place, but probably not the... More

I was craving a "smoothy" to help balance out all the rich, foods we were eating on our vacation - this cafe had exactly what I wanted. Lots of smoothy options as well as fresh juices (kale, beet etc.) and an AWESOME fish taco on tuesdays! The restaurant kitchen is tiny and shares a counter with the grocery part of... More

Had the Kimchee salad and the best raw coconut water I've had in my entire life. Nice outdoor tables. Loved it, and healthy portions.

We were in Montauk in September 2012 and ate at Naturally Good almost every morning (except for Anthony's for old time’s sake). Breakfast burrito's and pancakes were our staples. It's the little things like serving real maple syrup with the pancakes instead of plastic tubs of Log Cabins sugar syrup, and fresh made salsa for the burrito. For lunch, we... More

As a local to Montauk I have been to nearly every restaurant/cafe/bar but nothing compared to naturally good! I always feel good about what I'm getting there because its 100% organic everything and the atmosphere is always friendly and upbeat! This place is awesome!! :)

Amazing menu, excellent, caring service, high quality tasty food all generous portions and so, so yummy! Besides café there is a market…I thought most items were way overpriced but maybe it’s hard to get these products out to Montauk. Highly recommend the café for vegans, vegetarians, and even meat eaters! (They saved me, after a week of travel with no... More

Had tofu burrito 2 mornings in a row and excellent ... Being a gluten free vegan this was a good place to eat ...only wished it was open for dinner as well! This was my third time eating here overall!

Yes, I know I raved about Joni's waffles in another review :) , but we always go back to this place for the scrambled eggs, rice and beans. Good food that's good for you is the best way to put it. They also have a nicely stocked little market with helath foods, supplements, bulk grains, personal items like Tom's of... More

Loved the yogurt with fruit and granola, went back several times during our week stay in Montauk. They are really nice