OK, Rogue's Harbor has been (for quite a while) my favorite restaurant to go to. But something's amiss there right now. Could have just been an "off" night, but I'm not sure. Apparently there is a new chef in the house, and I'm not sure that is going to work out for them. The items I ordered this evening (French... More

We love traveling the half hour to Rogue's Harbor from our home. We especially enjoy going in summer and eating on the porch. Nice varied menu with a focus on NY-produced food and wine; they also brew their own beer. When I really crave a burger, this is where I go.

My husband & I visited on a Sunday evening. It was relatively quiet at about half capacity in the dinning room. This was our second visit to the restaurant. Our order was relatively simple - a burger with cold slaw, a salad with grilled chicken on top, and a flight of home brewed beers. The flight of beers was very... More

Located in an historic building, said to have been a stop on the Underground Railroad and also to have been a hot spot during the Prohibition years, Rogue's Harbor provides a variety of great food for all tastes. Many of the ingredients are locally farmed/raised. My favorite dish is the Wild Mushroom Ravioli; they also have some very good soups... More

My husband and I visit Rogue's Harbor as often as possible. It is one of our favorite restaurants in the Ithaca/Cortland area. The atmosphere is great, the servers are friendly, the food is excellent with lots of fresh/local products, and they even brew their own beer (you can get growlers to take home). They occasionally have live music in the... More

We visited the Finger Lakes & had dinner here 1 evening. It had a very charming atmosphere & the food was good. I ordered the French Onion Soup & the Mushroom Ravioli. I would recommend both.

very good meal, very good service, and lots of local/on-site beers to choose from. Also, local wines, and a dedication to using locally grown farm products.

We stopped for a drink and dinner on a Sunday evening. Our Cosmopolitans were a bit on the sweet side but not bad. We shared the Wanton Wontons which were stuffed with pork. They were very good.My husband has a huge steak that was cooked properly but he didn't care for the sauce. I loved the Grilled Caesar salad, grilled... More

The food was good but the portions were small. They say they give hearty portions but we didn't find that to be the case. With that said, the ambiance is increidbly beautiful and historical. The beer is great and the servioce was too.