We finally decided to try Brunello's which is around the corner from our house. I am totally unimpressed. To me the restaurant was too dark. We were not seated under one of the mini lights and I could not read the menu or really see what I was eating. The noise level s very loud - I know restaurants are... More

Three of us were headed to dinner last night at an inexpensive, local, hole-in-the-wall barbeque restaurant only to discover when we got there, that it had gone out of business. Diagonally across the street from this now-defunct place was Brunello Trattoria...a restaurant we had thought about trying but had not yet made it there. Well despite the fact that we... More

I've tried this place on two occasions. Once right after they opened and again recently. The atmosphere is nice but the food is just average to me and the prices are a bit steep in my opinion. There are other options nearby that are a much better value.

Just ate here this evening for the first time. We took a chance based on all the great reviews from all others on this site. I cannot tell you how absolutely wonderful it was. The place is not at all where you'd expect, let alone what you'd expect. It's small, and well kept. The staff is extraordinarily attentive, but NOT... More

Brunello is located in the middle of nowhere opposite a feed store on the outskirts of Flemington. The location has consistently hosted Italian restaurants with food of exceptional quality. We didn't realize it was operational again - Then we discovered Brunello Trattoria has been there for two years! Wine list starts at $ 25/bottle and you get a decent bottle!... More

Dined with my husband and daughter for her 26th birthday Sunday night and had an appetizer -Portobello mushrooms (that we split) three delicious meals-chicken, Scottish salmon, and pasta, and chocolate mousse cake (that we split) for dessert. The attention to detail, and the service were incredible. Please check out their luncheon specials for $10. It is a feast!! My husband... More

We visited Brunello Trattoria with friends Saturday 01/21/12. The food and service were excellent. Chicken Parmigiana with Angel Hair Pasta was exceptional. Portabella Mushrooms for appetizer were the best we ever had. My wife had the Chilean Sea Bass, one of the day's specials...fantastic! A cozy and friendly atmosphere. Despite a day of snow/bad weather the restaurant was bustling. The... More

An old location with a very good new restaurant that is worth another look. There have been restaurants at the location outside Flemington on Old Croton Road for more than 35 years. This latest iteration is the best. Excellent, fresh, ingredients, are lovingly prepared. A risotto del giorno with shrimp and scallops was a scrumptious dinner entrée. Their gnocchi Bolognese... More