This place was discovered by our son using yelp, and we were so happy he found it! Not only were all three of our meals delicious (yellowtail snapper and yellowfin tuna were incredible), but our waitress was a sweetheart who chatted lightly to us, and made the experience even better. Every member of the staff was friendly and helpful. Beautiful... More

After a long day of snorkeling we decided to stop into the Buzzard's Roost. We were craving a big juicy hamburger and Yelp recommended them. So, we decided to give it a shot. I am very conflicted on this place, because the burger was honestly the best burger I have ever had in the Keys. But the service was very... More

My family and I have eaten at the Buzzard's Roost for quite a few years now... on average, once a month for lunch. The food here is good to very good and consistent in quality. Nothing to really blow your socks off but sometimes you just want an old favorite without a lot of fuss. I like the fresh catch... More

Dinner was just okay. The food was exactly like the art on the wall; local, pushed hard by the waiter, and not memorable. Folks were nice enough, but our appetizers and fish were blah. Now, the coconut cake was superb. Really, really good. Otherwise, I would have offered a poor rating.

I visited this restaurant twice in the last few weeks. Both times the food was great. One with a date for Sunday am brunch and once for dinner. Although they advertise on the ocean, it is on a canal that leads to the ocean. It is very nice quiet. I watched boats coming and going. Very pleasant. I would recommend... More

We went for a birthday dinner and both our pricey entrees were decidedly average. Hogfish, known for its sublime and unique taste, arrived smothered in some overpowering sauce that masked any hint of the fish and left me wondering if it was really hogfish under there. The waitstaff are wonderful - friendly and engaging (particularly Jim) and the happy hour... More

Based on reviews here, my wife and I decided to seek out this place for lunch, and it was very easy to find, although it's not on the Overseas Highway. It's on the water at a marina, which gives it a pleasant atmosphere. Our waiter was very friendly and efficient, and our fish sandwiches were very good, served up with... More

It must have been an off night. Arrived for my reservation at 8 pm and no hostess at the front station. It took them almost 15 minutes for someone to stop by and let us know they would be right with us. By then there were three other parties waiting to be seated. They must have been very understaffed. We... More

We enjoyed an evening of live music and tasty food during our first visit to the BR. Get there early, it does get packed during the dinner hours. We had a 20 minute wait. Ordered some drinks at the bar and walked around outside during our wait. Live music this night. Fun relaxing perk!! Ate in the screened area, good... More