I love, love, love this place! Prices aren't bad, food is excellent and so is the service! Never have I had a steak so tender I could cut it with a fork!!!
Great place, locals know about but not well advertised. Friendly people...older establishment but sparkling clean, quick service, and the steak was perfectly prepared. Judging by the number of people waiting for the doors to open, it must be good!
This place was recommended by the hotel front desk. The steak was prepared perfectly. My coworkers had the salad as side, straight out of the bag with a tomatoe on top. Skip the salad and get another side. I had brocolli which was cooked perfectly and a sweet potatoe. The atmosphere is nothing to brag about but the steak was... More
Just passing through Dothan and stopped here after reading reviews. So glad we did . Perfectly prepared ,quality steaks . Ask for their house steak sauce, and there house made cheesecake is fantastic too. This is a casual ,locals,steakhouse. Great staff, great food.
not sure of the history, somehow the family or friends were related and split up. Doesn't matter though, between old mill and conestoga, you cannot go wrong with a steak. They can make a sirloin steak taste great (but why would one ever want to eat a sirloin when you can order a filet or new york strip)
This was another Dothan local favorite but a little bit of a hole in the wall place. It is right on 231 but still a little hard to see, limited parking and a little dumpy inside and out. When they say a steak house that is exactly what they mean. I had never seen a menu that literally had nothing... More
If you want an excellent steak, this is the place to go. If you require your steak in a fancy environment, this is not the place to go. This restaurant was recommended by the lady at the bank who was opening a student account for our daughter. She said it is a hole in the wall, but she really likes... More
Overall...better than a chain steak place but not up to par for foodies. Arrived at 4:30pm on a Saturday and was surprised to see a parking lot full of cars. Entered to find a waiting list for tables. Although very busy I was seated within 15min and promptly greeted by my waitress who was very friendly. I was pleased that... More
Conestoga was recommended by numerous individuals in the local area. Service was quick; seating was timely though a short wait was necessary even at early dining. Easy to understand the numerous recommendations as the meal exceeded expectations. Fresh hot rolls with a well chilled fresh salad with choice of dressing. Recommend dressing on the side as it is liberally applied... More
If you own or manage Conestoga Steak House, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing