Visited midweek with colleagues and friends whilst visiting Sheffield on a conference. Really liked the ambience and atmosphere even though relatively quiet that night. Menu a little limited midweek but apparently locally sourced ingredients. Cooking was good but not exceptional. Tasty pies, really good dessert. Some pretty decent wine. Good value for money, just don't expect it to be Gordon... More

After seeing a Facebook post for the weekday menu we decided to book a table and the food was just wonderful. We thought it was a little naughty that the side dishes were extra on top of the £14.95 for two courses as advertised as they are really required but otherwise we could not fault the food, the service or... More

First time of dining at Silversmiths which was touch and go because they were fully booked and couldn't accommodate us at 5:30! I was quite pleased in a way - must be popular if they are full at that time. We dined at 6:15 with barely 1 1/2 hours before our train was due. Considering I usually spend a minimum... More

Booked a table at 21:00 - apparently the theatre crowd book early so no tables for 19:30 - 20:30, when arrived restaurant was half empty. Happy, friendly if amateurish service. I guess some students getting some extra cash. Food ranged from excellent to average. Meats were good and well cooked, portions on small side. Vegetarian options also tasty and on... More

I visited on May 18th with my partner to celebrate 15 years together. We had 3 courses each and two drinks. The bill was around £70. I am honestly struggling to find any fault at all with this restaurant. Delicious food, friendly staff, great venue. I can't recommend it highly enough.

Interestingly we visited Silversmiths on the same date (April 27th) as the previous reviewer and thought the food was excellent. My wife and I attended prior to going to the Lyceum theatre and took advantage of the early bird offer. The portions are on the small side and some people may feel the need to purchase further side dishes to... More

Visited this restaurant with friends on 27 April. Staff were pleasant enough, but things went downhill when the food arrived. Examples are as follows. Carpaccio of venison was presented as a plate of rocket salad smothered in some kind of sauce and if you were lucky you could find one or two thin narrow slivers of meat which could have... More

The service from start to finish was very friendly without being pushy. The restaurant has a lovely atmosphere and is great for a meal for two. Having said that they can accommodate larger groups-there was a big group on the old stage while we were there. The 3 courses for £16.90 Wednesday and Thursday is good value. We had 2... More

Booked online, for a saturday night,got phone and text confirmation. Arrived early, as soon as we walked, it felt like home. The staff were friendly and very knowledgable. Promoting the cocktail of the week. It worked, we enjoyed 4 of them. The starters of rolled pigs head and black pudding, and chicken terrine were a great way to whet the... More