Pizza was good, ambiance is so-so, service was good, price was high, even by Eleuthera standards. But I would definitely go again.

We arrived early, first ones there. Nice staff, recommended we order half and half because we each wanted something different. The pizza took about 20 minutes, about right. The crust was light and a little crispy, perfect. They apparently do a good takeout business too.

Neat, clean, friendly staff and fantastic ham & pineapple pizza means "I'll be back"! Best pizza I've had in a long time.

My wife and I stopped by here to try the pizza we'd heard about from a few people, and reviews. It was very good. We were conched out by the time we stopped by, but we've heard it's their specialty. We had a supreme, and it was awesome.

average, not terrible, not much of a social gathering that ive seen, the people seem to have friendly faces which is good, looks like this place was a huge hit in the past... as of now not much of a hangout spot?hmmmm.

Ready quickly, good and hot! Crust is nice and light. Just what the doctor ordered after a long day at lighthouse beach!

We had both the ham & pineapple and conch pizza and both were good. we got take out on 2 occasions. Service was excellent when we ate their on their little porch out front. Kaliks were nice & cokld.

Mate and Jenny's is a friendly little pizza place popular with both locals and tourists. Mate also serves fish and you place your order and he sends his son out to catch whatever you ordered. Very friendly and sometimes fairly lively place with a small dance floor. Nothing fancy, just friendly locals and nicely done pizza, conch, and fish prepared... More

We went to Mate & Jenny's for lunch on a Wednesday. There was only one other table, but we had to wait five minutes to get any attention from the waitress (she saw us and chose to ignore our presence). We asked to sit on the porch, and she told us to pick up placemats and silverware and seat ourselves.... More