Beautiful setting with a wonderful menu. You must try the Escovitched fish dish. The service is impeccable.

Everything at Sugar Mill was top notch. The restaurant itself was elegant with a beach feel. The service was impeccable and the food was wonderful. I was highly reccommend this restaurant to anyone staying in Montego Bay.

We went to the Sugar Mill on March 16, 2013. As soon as we drove up we were impressed at the vintage water wheel that was the back drop for romantic evening. We were immediately greeted as we walked by the hostess. Our reservation was quickly found and we were immediately seated. Our server (Gaven) was at our table within... More

They screwed up my dinner reservations on the first night, that I had made weeks in advance (and confirmed multiple times), and when I got to the Sugar Mill, they had to seat some of my party at one table, some at another, and some at yet another. I had to shag down a waiter twice to get him to... More

The Sugar Mill is a very nice restaurant located on the golf course at the Half Moon Resort. Excellent food (but pricey with the least expensive main course at $36) with good service and pleasant surroundings. Our best dining experience in the Montego Bay area.

I had dined here once before on my first trip to Jamaica in September 2007. It left such an impression on me then that I convinced my group of 19 that I was travelling with this time that it was a must-do. Everything about this restaurant is phenomenal. The wait staff is incredibly attentive and makes excellent food recommendations. The... More

I would say the food is good, not great. We had some nice apps and split the catch of the day but the fish was dry..so we were disappointed. The night befor we went to Margarites which had great food but a weird vibe.. The atmosphere at Sugar Mill was better and our asst waiter, Newton, was a hoot! He... More

Romantic Dinner, Great Food. Service was fabulous. Great wine selections. We were on an all-inclusive plan but wine selections were too good to pass up. I had the SeaBass and my husband had the Rib Eye both meals fabulous. Took dessert home as we were stuffed but could not pass it up ate it later and it was great.

This was the best place we ate on our trip. It's pricey, as expected, but the outdoor patio was beautiful and the service was very good. The food was excellent. As we walked through the restaurant on our way out to our table, it was very well done too. We ate on the later side, so it wasn't too full,... More