Came here for an off-season break and found a quiet beautiful spot. After driving round lots this was the nicest b&b location we saw on shelter island - house and view of the creek are gorgeous. The downstairs suite with a separate sitting room is full of old school charm, great big boat-like sofa, old furniture and tasteful decor. The... More

My wife and I enjoyed a wonderful, wintry two-night stay on Shelter Island (our first visit), in large part because the House on Chase Creek is such a pleasant place to stay. Bill is a friendly yet unobtrusive host, and his local knowledge and dining recommendations were especially helpful and perfect for us. (The Pharmacy for the hash browns; Star's... More

My husband and I just spent the most lovely weekend at The House on Chase Creek. We love to find rooms in the winter where we can enjoy a fire. The suite has a very large sitting room with a fireplace and a very bright bedroom with a view of the water. The fire was perfectly built, you literally just... More

After resigning the idea of slogging through hectic travel hubs for the holidays, my partner and I turned to House on Chase Creek for a serene Christmas vacation. The trip exceeded our expectations as the home proved to be neatly kept, properly serviced, snugly located on a convenient riverfront cove, and very, very private. Shelter Island oozes charm, and we... More

My wife and I needed to get away and clear our heads even if it was just for a weekend. Decided to go to Shelter Island since we both were never there. I booked House on Chase Creek after reading the reviews and was very satisfied. The owner was extremely nice and hospitable. The rooms were very clean and smelled... More

We were looking for a much-needed escape over the Columbus Day weekend, and The House on Chase Creek was absolutely perfect for this. Peace and quiet is what we sought, and that is what we got, with a serene and picturesque view as well. What a pretty place! This was a great home base from which to go bicycle riding,... More

We decided to go out the North Fork of Long Island on our way from PA to Boston as alternative to the slog thru Connecticut, and wanted a place to spend the night before taking the ferry to New London. Bill at The House at Chase Creek was able to accommodate us for one night at this pretty place with... More

My husband, a friend and myself stayed at the House on Chase Creek a few weeks ago while visiting Shelter Island for a wedding. We rented the suite with a pull-out bed in the living area and queen-sized bed in the bedroom. The suite was charming and spotless. The bed was very comfortable and the linens high quality. Bill, the... More

I am referring to the review titled “disappointing” of September 4th and would advise you to IGNORE IT! We are loyal customers of House on the Chase Creek and we highly recommended it to our friends, who extremely enjoyed the stay. Unfortunately all of us made the big mistake to recommend it to the writer of the review which is... More