Terrible. We called to book a room despite the intriguing reviews. Well, after few questions to get a better idea of the location and the quietness of the area, the answer we had was "if you want some quiet place you should go to a cemetery. CRAZY. We will never advise this place to anybody.

I booked Stearn point House back in March for my wedding guests. My wedding is in August. I visited the B&B back in April and met with the manager, she sounded nice. I only talked to the owner by phone, at first she sounded ok. I sent her the requested deposit in order to book the rooms etc. We then... More

I stayed their recently for a weekend visit to Shelter Island with a galpal. This was one of the few places on the island that happened to have last minute availability. It was clean and charming. Maria, who runs the property together with David, is happy to share local knowledge. They have a nice porch which is great for breakfast... More

Stayed at Stearns Point House in Shelter Island this Summer. Clean and very basic, the managers Dave and Marie were great. Breakfast was ok, with fresh coffee, OJ, milk, muffins, bread, donuts, fruits. The building is an old farm of sorts, very basic with the land not that impressive, the grass field out front really in poor shape - don't... More