woke up,decided to take a ride.I called one place ,they said they had a oceanfront room available.We b ooked and told them we would be there in a couple of hours.Upon arriving and asking to see the room,my first question was "who died in here".smelled terrible,no view at all and overpriced.With no place to stay,we checked out a few,called a... More

Just finished a week stay. This was our second year at the Beachcomber. Whole family loved it, pool , beach, and short walk to town. Bonfires on the beach our favorite part. We will be back next year. More

We had a great vacation at the Beachcomber, all the rooms, including the kitchenette and bathroom, were very clean. The kitchenette was fully stocked to make any meal we wanted. The beach was great and it was just a short walk into town ( I recommend the big burger at Johns Drive In). The wifi was a little slow at... More

Let me start by saying that we love staying in Montauk and have stayed @ the Beachcomber numerous times before without ever having a problem like this. I am usually NOT the type of person to complain and always will give praise when deserving. That being said, this was the single worst experience of lack of customer service that my... More

Our family of 3 started a 9 day NE vacation with our 2nd and 3rd nights at the Montauk Beachcomber Resort Hotel. Because I used Tripadvisor to select all hotels and restaurants on this trip - I am adding comments for each of the 9 days! Not one disappointment - all comments on Tripadvisor are very accurate and I appreciated... More

Great view of the water, nice large unit with small kitchenette. Only complaint was we could never connect to the wifi, we were given the wrong password, but even with the correct password, we could never get a connection. More

This was an ok hotel. The pool is nice and it is very close to the beach. The rooms are clean but dated. They say it is a 10 minute walk to town but it is really a 10 minute walk to the edge of town and a 20 minute walk into the center of town. There isn't a restaurant... More

The Beachcomber is right across the street from the beach, and the paths to the beach have recently been widened and cleaned. The reason to stay at the Beachcomber is for its location. There are breathtaking views of the beach from almost every room, and it is a short walk away from the beach. It is also close enough so... More

We love the Beachcomber. We've never had a problem or a bad stay here. The beach is right across the street, the rooms are spacious, the location is convenient. It's not the most luxurious place, but that's the Montauk "thing". We always have a fun, romantic time. Don't forget your flashlights and firewood for on the beach bonfires! More