It was a nice stay. We had the standard room, a little outdated, but nice, clean and big. The location was convinient for us as I was staying with a friend for a wedding party in Mineola, Long Island. I have no complaints and the service was professional, quick and helpful.

I stayed here for a night on a business trip. The hotel building and approach is impressive. The reception staff were friendly. I had booked a larger room, which turned out to be totally unnecessary. It was two large double rooms: one with a large bed and large bathroom, and the other had a sofa, armchairs, dining table and kitchenette.... More

My husband and I stayed there for a night and the following day, we had our wedding brunch celebration. The room was super spacious and we had more space than we could imagine! We reserved a 'standard' room and were upgraded for free!! Service was great, the staff was accommodating and it felt like a 'mini-vacation'. We knew we were... More

This is a very pretty hotel, well preserved, with excellent service throughout. Rooms and bathrooms were of decent size with all the amenities you would expect of a nice hotel. It is located near major shopping, dining and event venues making it a convenient choice for those needing a hotel for a night or two. Valet parking is available or... More

First time staying here, I had high hopes but they were shot down. Ancient furniture, not even antique just old, stained and badly chipped. The decor is hideous and the bathroom was dirty and cracked tile floor. The whole vibe was off...for the price go it sucked! Didn't even stay the whole night I was so grossed out...very disappointing!

Awesome stay at Garden City Hotel!! The staff was so friendly and kind!! They were very attentive and really made the stay incredible!! Even the pool staff and maintenance staff went above and beyond!! The pool was wonderful and kept so warm , awesome!!!! Thankyou Thankyou thankyou!!!!

I took more pics, see for yourself , Dated , worn, pool tile has oil and dead skin on water line, unsanitary, hot tub has been closed for 2 years so they built over it, hotel room bathroom have dirty grout, moldy shower curtain, the heating / cooling unit is very loud

After an amazing to day stay in Tarrytown for a wedding.We were looking forward to exploring more of new York as we came in from California and this was our first time here, every one from the door man to the front desk to the wait staff greeted us with big smiles and were very pleasant. The Hotel it self... More

Now that my husband is over a serious illness, we wanted to take a little "staycation." We were able to get a good rate through an on-line site at the Garden City Hotel. I was initially put off by the man at the front desk who absolutely refused to let us into a room at 2:30, since check-in was at... More