I stayed at this hotel for a business meeting (we had the meeting in Newark to support the local economy - rightfully so) and this was one of the worst hotel meetings I've attended (I go to meetings at hotels at least once a month) because of poor service. While the meeting room was spacious, the quality of service was... More

Got a good deal here during Labor Day 2011 weekend for a 2-night NYC trip. Hotel is less than 10min walk from Newark Penn station - there's shuttle service provided by the hotel, but since it's on demand, I found it faster to simply walk to the station. From Penn, you can catch PATH for 2.00, takes 22min to get... More

I found the hotel to be convient for our need, to communte to and from NY, Car rental nearby. The room was decent, clean comfortable. the breakfast was adquate, people need to understand that continental, does not mean full spread. The shuttle service great, to the airport. resturants are nearby. The complaint that I have is the parking situation, the... More

My husband has worked in hotels for 10 years now. We booked this for his birthday to spend just the night- thank god! We are 28 and 22 (obviously a young couple that doesn't mind noise, but this is rediculous) Pros: Location Cons: Service was terrible, bed was stiff, parking was close and free (as advertised) but it wasn't exclusively... More

The hotel is really nice and the staff is very responsive, freandly and helpful. There is a free shuttle service runnig 24/7 from/to airport and Newark Central Station. One can also order the service by phone, e.g. to be picked up from the central station at night. The breakfast is a joke, but it is okay if one expects nothing... More

We needed a hotel for the night prior to a flight out of the area. I guess I wanted something more than the typical airport hotel, but I didn't want to pay New York/Newark area prices for a room. The rates at Robert Treat were so low that I was very hesitate to stay there. I expected a run-down dump.... More

Our room had no heat, and the wireless internet did not work. When we spoke to the front desk, they were totally uninterested in our complaint, We then wrote an email to the general manager, we did not even receive a reply. More

I stayed for 1 week in May because I needed to be in this neighborhood. Now Newark is NOT a place that people generally want to be in, but sometimes business requires it. And as Newark goes, I think this is the best hotel taking into account both location, comfort and value. The only other hotel around here that is... More

First and foremost, I thought that the staff was very friendly, helpful, and nice. It was clean and comfortable. As others have said, the breakfast was ok, but they could do a lot better. We were looking for a cost effective stay for a weekend in NYC and that is what we got. I found the PATH train experience a... More