Writing this review a little late, like almost a year! The wife and I stayed here for the second time in April 2012. It was just as we remembered although there was a new host with Peter and his wife. Same great breakfasts and coffee, beautiful setting just set back enough where you feel you're in the jungle but close... More

Our hosts, Mickey and Frank, made our nine-night stay the perfect vacation on St. John. The rooms are well appointed with a caribbean flair, and they are absolutely spotless. Frank made wonderful breakfasts; my personal favorite was Eggs Benedict, but the piña colada French Toast and everything else was equally as yummy. We enjoyed talking to Mickey, and she shared... More

The B&B was a welcome change from our first four nights at a resort on St. Thomas. Upon arrival, one of our hosts, Frank, greeted us and said, "Welcome home." This pretty much sums up how we felt throughout our stay. Frank and Mickey were delightfully warm, knowledgeable, and sweet. We felt truly at home at Garden by the Sea,... More

I picked The Garden of the Sea after I read the reviews and it did not disappoint. I will echo all of the other positive comments and reiterate that Mickey and Frank are the most gracious hosts we have ever experienced at a B&B. The breakfasts were incredible and we really looked forward to planning our day with Frank. He... More

I very really write a review, but having stayed at Garden By The Sea for the second time and again having a great time, I was prompted to write. This is a small intimate B and B on the lovely island of St. John. The rooms are all very unique, some with open air showers. What makes it so special... More

Garden by the Sea provides the best accommodation on the island! My husband and I enjoyed six days at the B&B staying in the Terrace View room. This place truly lives up to the excellence guests have posted on Trip Advisor. Mickey and Frank are a dynamic duo and know how to ensure guests feel welcome, well fed, and inspired... More

What does most to make a B&B special are the people who run it. Although not the owners, Mickey and Frank, the husband and wife who run this place, could not be better at what they do. Mickey greeted us with such genuine warmth that we immediately felt welcome and Frank was equally nice and could not have been more... More

My Husband and I came to St.Thomas for my great grandmother's 100th birthday, but we wanted to stay in ST. Johns, so glad we did! Had a great time, so peaceful and relaxing. Although we took the ferry to ST. Thomas almost everyday, we did spend some time hanging out at the beach and had breakfast every morning with Frank... More

My husband and I just returned from six nights at Garden by the Sea. Mickey and Frank (who manage the B&B six months out of the year) were great hosts, and we would definitely stay here again! The hospitality started six months before our trip with numerous emails from me to Nancy (who owns the B&B and manages it the... More