I must make it clear from the beginning. Nothing wrong with the property. Very good rooms excellent location. BUT the bar closes at 5pm. No restaurant for dinner (breakfast opens at 07.30) and the reception starts at 08.00. A hotel in a private island whith a priveleged location after 5pm becomes merely a motel with only available coin machines for... More

a short hop from Christiansted but on your own private beach-wonderful wild life-birds-iguanas-hermit crabs-and the ocean right at your feet fresh flowers in the room were a wonderful surprise beds very comfortable and the atmosphere was restful

We purchased a 4 night stay on LivingSocial and the value of the promo was worth what we paid. The island was cute and clean and we enjoyed the ferry rides to and from the cay to main island. I would recommend tourists to stay at Hotel on the Cay. We felt safe in our rooms and I liked being... More

80's decor, outdated, rust on the wall, dirt on the walls, broken bathroom mirror. Overall dirty. Amazing location with allot of potential. But the rooms are horrendous! Staff was not friendly and could not be bothered. Water sport rental shop never open.

Hotel on the Cay was a wonderful place to stay. It provides a great view and depending on who is running the front desk - the service is good too. HOWEVER: The boat travel to and from gets really annoying if you are there for an extended period of time (week or more). Most of the phones in the rooms... More

This was my first trip to St. Croix and I loved it! While the hotel is a little dated it serves its purpose, is very clean, and has all of the necessities. The beach on the island is perfect with beach chairs and cabanas for guests and the beach bar there for any food or drink needs. There is also... More

I love this hotel - we go back every year, often with family or friends. It's casual and friendly, very affordable, with seriously exquisite views in every direction from every room we've ever stayed in. Gorgeous powder-fine white sand, awesome tropical drinks at the beachfront restaurant, lovely pool. If you want fine carpets, egyptian cotton sheets and room service, go... More

Have been to St Croix twice in the past 3 years, stayed at the HOTC both times. We are staying there again with 3 other couples from last year, again next month. It is a little dated, but appears to have a serious renovation plan constantly taking place for the whole facility, and the improvements are obvious. Most of the... More

This was our first trip to St Croix. The HOTC was recommended by some friends who had stayed there previously. It definitly was not a 4 or 5 star accommodation, but is was very enjoyable. It does need some work but it is right on the ocean and anyone with ocean side experience knows maintenance is a constant. The staff... More