a few good things...putt putt golf, really great buckeye ice cream, and a bakery with the best baked goods ever.
When you're on Kelley's Island, make sure to visit Caddy Shack Square. It has something for everyone -- putt-putt golf, ice cream, bicycle and golf cart rentals, shops, a restaurant and inside/outside bars. On the weekend nights, a band or DJ is there for entertainment, but even more entertaining is watching people get crazy. Get the pizza - It's very... More
Well I hate dancing, but it is a great place. During the day kids will love the putt-putt, ice cream, food & can rent bikes. I think you can rent golf carts too, but I may be wrong there. There is shopping and very close to other restaurants, bars & shopping. In my opinion they have some of the best... More
There's really not a whole lot of variety on Kelleys Island, so we thought pizza would be a safe choice. We had to wait forever, but to be fair the place was rather busy. When we finally got our pizza, it was disappointing as it didn't have much taste. I've rarely met a pizza I didn't like, but this really... More
It's small, but a lot to do unless you place miniature golf. A few good shops. Worth a visit. Like the bakery. The General Store across the street had a lot of items we purchased as gifts - go there.
Screams "Vacation!" Lots of signs, outdoor tables, bar next door to restaurant (with own bar), next door to....souveniers, coffee shop, ice cream stand. Family ate in restaurant, more like a beach bar in decor, with music inside and out. You line up to order at the window from chalked-in menus on wall- we got pizzas only having been told that... More
There was a grouchy lady at the rental counter that was telling people not to swing their putt putt clubs. They were out of 2 person carts and the grouch would not let us rent hourly to start and give us the four hour discount if we kept the cart for that long. After some research, we decided to get... More
Little plaza of shops on the Island. There were a couple different overpriced touristy type stores + a putt putt golf course + an ice cream place. Probably worth stopping in and checking out. Why not?
pizza has been good for years. We have been to the islands for decades, and Caddy Shack has always been part of our Kelleys Island experience.
If you own or manage Caddy Shack Square, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing